This post is dedicated to my early days of prospecting and the late, great Tom Underwood. Underwood died last week at age 56 after battling pancreatic cancer.
The news stopped me for a moment because just last week I had pulled Underwood's 1976 Topps rookie cup card while looking for cards to feature on the "Top 60 Ever" posts. How freaky is it to look at a card that you haven't viewed in a year or two and find out that the player had died that same week? That still floors me.
I thought Underwood was going to be a great player in 1976. I had no idea what prospecting was then. Nobody did. But I kept that card under a close eye, because he was going to transform the Philadelphia Phillies pitching staff into something epic. Steve Carlton, watch your back, because a new ace was in town.
That never happened. Underwood had a respectable career, but he wasn't an ace for the Phillies, or the Cardinals (horrible airbrushing job in '78 Topps), or the Blue Jays, or the Yankees, or the A's, or the Orioles.
Actually, there was no way for me to know whether Underwood would become a star. We didn't have the internet or Baseball America or Bowman or anything really to help us figure out how to project a career. All we had was a rookie cup.
Anyway, before this gets all Cardboard Appreciationy and I forget I'm supposed to be featuring the 1981 set, here's Underwood's card back from '81:
In many ways it is your basic card back of its time. But 1981 Topps sets itself apart in two ways.
First, it added a few more columns of stats for pitchers. Stats for games started, complete games, shutouts and saves were all new in 1981. For years, the traditional columns for pitchers were G, IP, W, L, R, ER, SO, BB, ERA. So this was a significant addition.
Topps also added four more categories for hitters. Stolen bases, slugging percentage, walks and strikeouts were all new (I was always frustrated as a kid that Topps cards of the 1970s did not feature stolen base stats).
Topps would stay with that same stat configuration for both hitters and pitchers for the next 23 years, until making a change in 2004 by adding OPS for hitters and WHIP for pitchers.
Below the stats, you'll note the brief write-up on the bottom of Keith Moreland's card. Fascinating, isn't it? That's one of the drawbacks of the '81 Topps set. It would feature cartoons for players who didn't have long careers, or at least not a lot of minor league stats, but merely a sentence write-up or nothing at all for those with a bunch of stats. That's a big card back countdown no-no.
But for the cards that did have cartoons, the collector was in for a treat.
For me, the 1981 set marked the end of the golden age of Topps cartoons. There were some cartoon in the '82 set, but they were very sporadic and dull. After that, there was nothing until 2006.
But the 1981 cartoons contained multiple features that I enjoyed. One of them was that there were two cartoons for each card. That was something that hadn't been employed since the 1960s. And I particularly enjoyed it when the cartoons were related to each other.
Ben Henry from The Baseball Card Blog devoted several posts to the 1981 cartoons a couple of years ago. I believe this one was one of the finalists in the tournament he held.
The combination of these two cartoons is mildly disturbing.
The other thing that I like about the cartoons is that Topps seemed to get a lot of good information from its player surveys in 1981. Here are my favorites:
My all-time favorite is the last one. I'd have you guess each of these but I doubt anyone would get more than two or three. So here's the order from top to bottom:
1. Joe Charboneau
2. Doug Capilla
3. Mark Fidrych
4. Roy Lee Jackson
5. Lance Parrish
6. Bob Davis
7. Doug Collins
8. Dick Davis
9. Biff Pocoroba
10. Bob McClure
11. Bill Travers
12. Jeff Reardon
13. Bucky Dent
14. Jim Kern
I love the tone of the Pocoroba cartoon: "No, really! His parents actually named him that! Really! It's true!" Also, I suspect Bob Davis was pulling Topps' leg.
Best of the set:
I must go with The Kid.
He collected baseball cards!
(Previous card back countdown selections):
50. 1978 SSPC Yankee Yearbook
49. 1993 Score
48. 1999 Skybox Thunder
47. 2000 Upper Deck
46. 1999 Skybox Premium
45. 1953 Johnston Cookies Braves
44. 1995 Topps
43. 1997 Fleer
42. 1992 Pinnacle
41. 1989 Bowman
40. 1977 Kellogg's
39. 2004 Topps
38. 2004 Topps Total
37. 1992 Topps
36. 1992 Donruss
35. 2008 Upper Deck Documentary
34. 1963 Fleer
33. 1955 Bowman
32. 2006 Topps
31. 1961 Topps
30. 1955 Topps
29. 1967 Topps
28. 1970 Topps
27. 1969 Topps
26. 1966 Topps
25. 1963 Topps
24. 1911 T205
23. 1962 Topps