Skip to main content

Cardboard appreciation: cards 41-47

(Happy Veterans Day! I salute my dad and all other veterans out there. I know there are several in the card blogging community. Bless you and thank you. You are appreciated. And speaking of appreciation, it's time for Cardboard Appreciation):

For Cardboard Appreciation Vote-Off #8, I expected this card to win:

And it did win. It enters the list of finalists in the great Cardboard Appreciation Smorgasbord of Trading Card Wonderfulness.

But so does this card:
This card managed to tie Carew in the poll. It was a hard-fought battle throughout. Off-center McRae would not be denied. And the two cards ended deadlocked.

Here are the vote totals:

Rod Carew, 1975 Topps: 11 votes
Hal McRae, 1982 Fleer: 11 votes
Grady Hall, 1991 Line Drive: 7 votes
Ozzie Guillen, 1997 Stadium Club: 6 votes
Johnny Cueto, 2008 Stadium Club autograph: 0 votes

So, that means with the two additions I am going to end up with 10 Cardboard Appreciation Vote-off finalists as originally planned. So I'll be going back to that original plan for the finalists and pair them up two-by-two until I end up with a Final Five.

But before I do that, I must have Vote-Off #9. And I am bunching a few extra cards into this final vote-off.

Also, some of the card choices may seem kind of lame. That's because with some of the cards, the story behind the card is better than the card. So you might have to click on the links to get the full background.

Here are the candidates. Poll is up on the sidebar:
Barry Larkin, 1988 Topps: I may be the only one, but I think '88 Topps was a classy design, one of the best of the '80s. And Larkin was among my favorite cards in the set.

Prince Fielder, 2009 O-Pee-Chee: This card sums up how much I love baseball. I seek out games that feature the Pirates playing the Brewers. The more obscure the game, the better.

J.R. Richard, 1980 Kellogg's: How do you make a box of cereal cool? You're looking at the answer.

Benny Distefano, 1985 Topps: The last left-handed catcher to play in the major leagues. Lefties are a bit discriminated against in baseball, unless you can throw smoke -- and as a lefty, I'm mildly outraged.

John Pawlowski, 1988 Donruss: Who knew that the kid in the grade ahead of me would end up on a baseball card?

Hideo Nomo, 1996 Upper Deck V.J. Lovero insert set: I featured a bunch of Nomo cards on this post, so I picked the one I liked the best.

Andre Ethier, 2009 O-Pee-Chee black border: A quick-and-easy way to dress up a humdrum card: Slap a black border around it.

OK, this is your chance to round out the CA vote-off finalists! Which card will be the last to join the list? Do you care? You don't have to! Just vote. It'll get me off your back.


I'm going with J.R. for two reasons. It is one of the few Kellogg's cards I actually got in a box and that look on his face. I can just hear him saying, "Are you sure you want to crowd the plate? Ok, it's your funeral."
Two Packs A Day said…
Is there a way to vote for a tie? You did have to put 2 great cards in the same poll, making it hard for me to choose which one I like better. ;)
Johngy said…
Can't vote for Benny D., as he replaced my favorite Mike Squires as the answer to that lefty catcher question.
John P. gets my vote. Schoolmates rock. So if you ever put a card of Erik Pappas, it will get my vote.
Matt Runyon said…
Gotta go with the Kellogg's card. I wish they still made those cards.
Nachos Grande said…
Well, I'm obviously voting Larkin!
dayf said…
Oh my GOD. Prince looks like the Stay-Puft Marshmallow Man on that card. Nomo's the nicest, but I refuse to vote for a man who thieved Chipper's ROY award.
It looks like Hal McRae's helmet is popping off because he's leaning his head against the yellow box!

Popular posts from this blog

That was easy

   My approach on 2021 Topps, after seeing the cards, empty shelves and the tales of inflated prices, was that I could last the entire year without buying any.   The effort wasn't worth it. I'll just take my Dodgers and go home.   I went to Target once after the release date a couple weeks ago, I don't really remember what day I went, and saw empty shelves and shrugged.   So, move forward two weeks and it's birthday season. Those who have read this blog for awhile know I have a lot of birthdays in my family in March and it's the primary shopping time of the year, besides Christmas. I went to Target yesterday for a few items and I made sure to check the card aisle, just in case. I didn't expect to find anything, but I think you know me by now, I have to buy my first packs of the season if I have the opportunity. It's worth a look. The shelves seemed fairly empty as I approached. But they weren't. When I got there, I saw maybe six or seven 2021 Topps baseb

Reliving my childhood isn't easy

  My favorite part of collecting cards doesn't have to do with collecting current players, rookie cards or prospecting.   Although I pay attention to and buy modern cards and also seek out cards from before I was collecting or even before I was born, none of those cards are why I'm doing this.   The best part of collecting for me -- where the warm fuzzies reside, what I'd save for myself after chucking the rest of my collection -- is any card that was released when I was a child or young teen. I don't think I'm special in that way. A lot of collectors probably feel that way. But, unlike, say, the adult who grew up during the junk wax era, who can open pack after pack of 1990 Donruss and get that nostalgic rush without fear of packs ever disappearing, it's a little more difficult for me. I can go to a discount store a couple of miles away in town and grab some 1988 Donruss packs (I think I can still do that, who knows with the hobby weirdness lately). But there&#

G.O.A.T, the '80s: 20-11

  Big news at the night owl nest today. I subscribed to MLB.TV. Finally, I can watch any game I want this season. I no longer have to suffer with seeing the Mets play the Marlins for the 197th time or grit my teeth through Michael Kay because there's no baseball to watch anywhere else. I can ignore the Yankees for 162 games if I want! And that's what I plan to do. The Phillies-Orioles spring training game is on right now and then I'll search out something even more obscure later. I know, I know, I'm late to the party. That's the way it's been when it comes to entertainment viewing for most of my life. Taking years to land an MLB subscription was more of a cash-flow issue, but when I was younger, I'd miss out on the popular movies all the time because of a relatively sheltered existence. While high school classmates were quoting lines from Caddyshack and Stripes in the lunch room and on the school bus, I knew mostly Star Wars movies and E.T. HBO was the big t