Skip to main content

My kind of town (but not my kind of set)

There is only one town on the planet that I can say that I have visited five times that wasn't prompted by family, friends or work responsibilities.

That place, of course, is Cooperstown.

Since I was a tiny tyke, Cooperstown has always been just a drive away for me. Once I lived just to the south. Now I live just to the north. For those who have never been, it's everything you've heard. Small, quaint, picturesque and baseball everywhere.

But it's been awhile since I've visited, and I blame that on life, along with living with people who really don't give a damn about baseball.

For example, I was in a girly girl store today. I tried my best to look inconspicuous. But if a 40-something guy in a tiny store overrun with pink and purple doesn't scream "father shopping for Christmas" then I don't know what does. This is what I do now -- and have been doing -- instead of making day trips to Cooperstown. Enjoy it while you're young, day-trippers.

Just to take the edge off, I stopped at another nearby store, made a detour through the card aisle, and spotted a box of half-digested Panini Cooperstown. I grabbed five packs -- because that's all I can afford in the midst of Buy Me Something Or Else season.

You'll see four of the packs here. I saved one for A Pack To Be Named Later. It's up over there already.

Now, I'm normally not a Panini fan. No license and poorly designed cards is no incentive for me. But I have to admit that they've stepped up their game this year, enough for me to notice. I nabbed some packs of Triple Play and now they have this Cooperstown line, which is the first new all-legends card product in like five or six years.

So, that, alone deserves a listen.

And with that, here are four packs of Cooperstown. With the usual commentary featuring a half-hearted night owl.


#51 - Jimmie Foxx

OK, I'm going to get this out of the way early. I have read only vague references to what Panini did to avoid the whole "showing logos" thing. I can't figure out how people can just gloss over it when it's all I see.

On the majority of the cards, the top part of the frame cuts into the head of the player, obscuring the logo on the cap. By doing that Panini avoids the wrath of MLB, but also annoys the heck out of me. I can't stand it when design infringes on the photo (see 2008 Topps), and this is a major infringement. "LOOK OUT, YOU'RE GOING TO BUMP YOUR HE -- awww too late."

But if you can get past that, then this might be the set for you.

#149 - Tony Lazzeri

Poor Tony has a look on his face like he just hit his head. I wonder why?

#143 - Catfish Hunter

OK, I'll be nice now. The rest of the design is quite enjoyable. I like the "year of induction" element at the top. I like the Baseball Hall of Fame logo at the bottom. It has a classy look that fits in with the whole Cooperstown village theme. I just wish I could stop this constant urge to duck.

But back to positive, I enjoy the '70s ballplayers the most. Thank goodness Hunter is not pictured as a Yankee. In fact, this set lacks Mickey Mantle and Babe Ruth, for what I'm guessing are licensing issues. Now, there's incentive to collect the set!

Tom Seaver, Credentials insert, #1

There are several inserts with this set. This particular one is "Credentials" and might qualify as the most visually boring insert ever made.

I can appreciate the different fonts and all, but basic facts in various type-sizes does not qualify as a card front.

I actually like most of the inserts in this set a lot. This is the lone dud.

#3 - Honus Wagner

Now there's a nice card of the Flying Dutchman. Looks like he got his head down just in time, too.

Each pack comes with a sweepstakes card in which you can enter the accompanying code in a bid to win a 3-day trip to Cooperstown. Not exactly an exotic trip in these parts, but cool nonetheless.


#80 - Carl Yastrzemski

For some reason, the close-up shot seems to work better. I don't mind the cap cropping as much. In fact, I like the Yaz so much, let's turn the card over and look at the back.

The type in the write-up is pretty teensy. But I appreciate that most of the cards have a different picture on the back than on the front. And I always like the full-name treatment.

#37 - Frankie Frisch

Sorry, not going to show all the scans.

#126 - Buck Leonard

But I have to show that there are Negro League inductees in the set. That's certainly a bonus.

Nolan Ryan, Induction insert, #12

And that's certainly a better insert than the last one.

#31 - Harry Heilmann

Almost no one talks about Heilmann anymore. Not even Tigers fans. So that's why I scanned the card.


#9 - Alexander Cartwright

The "father of modern baseball" was a fire chief in Honolulu.

And now you know.

#67 - Dave Winfield

To me, Dave Winfield is a Padre, plain and simple. So I'm glad to see him as a Padre here, even though Panini is trying very hard to disguise the fact.

#156 - Al Simmons

The last 20 cards in the 170-card set are short-printed and all of those cards feature colorized photos. I don't know how common these SPs are -- there are no odds listed on the wrapper. But I'd say I did pretty good, considering someone just opened a box of this and pulled only two SPs.

#118 - Orlando Cepeda

#61 - Gaylord Perry

So close to being a photo of a headless pitcher.


#25 - Fred Clarke

#82 - Tommy Lasorda

The only Dodger I pulled from these packs. This photo reminds me of the stuff that Upper Deck used to do in its early days when they'd produce Dodgers with goofy photos because some dork didn't like the team.

If that's the plan, thwarted again. I like this picture.

#138 - Johnny Bench

Yup, horizontal cards, too. The person at lower left looks either very excited or very bored.

Luis Aparicio, High Praise insert, #1

The best-looking of the inserts I received. It features a complimentary quote about the presented player.

#19 - Paul Molitor

This is probably the closest thing I received to what you would get in a fully licensed set.

And there you are.

So, overview?

Glad there's a set out there recognizing just Hall of Famers. It's been too long.

Aside from that, it's a nice effort for having no license.

But in the end, there's no license.

And players bumping their heads against the top of the design.

So I won't be collecting it.

Cooperstown is my kind of town. But not exactly my kind of set.


Nick said…
You're lucky. I've been dreaming to go to Cooperstown for as long as I can remember. I'll get there one of these days.

Did you get these at Target? I went to check a few days ago, but mine didn't have anything.

I put a box of this set on my Christmas list. I'm not sure if that's because I like these or if I simply didn't have anything else to ask for.

I think it's just because it has been far too long since we've seen an all-legend set like Cooperstown. It's certainly not on the level of Fan Favorites or Legendary Cuts, but I'm still liking these nonetheless, even with the "head-banging" qualities.
Brad's Blog said…
I opened 2 boxes, definitly a fun break!
Sascards67 said…
I have not been able to bring myself to buy any Panini baseball products. If I'm going to have cards with no logos I'd rather have the oddball food sets from the 80's and 90's.
night owl said…
Yes, Nick, they came from Target.
Fuji said…
Not a big fan of non-licensed products, but I applaud Panini for their photo selection.

The Credentials insert is pretty ridiculous... looks better as a card back. In fact, IMO they should use it as the Induction insert card back.
Zayden said…
I've been to Cooperstown a couple times when I was a kid and I must say these cards don't seem to capture Cooperstown at all.

Something just ain't quite right and I don't know what it is.

Perhaps it's the framing or perhaps like you said... They keep bumbing their heads lol : )
Been there twice and would love to go again.

I just found some of these in Target tonight.6 packs, no colored short prints,but I do like the cards and plan to go after the set.
AdamE said…
I like the Yaz. I really need to send out that Garvey stuff I have for ...
Commishbob said…
If you go to Cooperstown and don't take the short walk to the south edge of Ostego Lake and take in the view, you're cheating yourself. I absolutely love the area from there east to the Hudson and down to Tarrytown. I'd like to retire to there one day soon.

The cards of the 'old timers' work better for me because I'm more used to seeing them without a cap logo, or at least I don't miss it as much. The Honus Wagner is a pretty nice card.
I haven't been on the card aisle in so long I didn't even know these existed. I like the Bench and the Lasorda is pretty quirky.
Anonymous said…
You go college at Oneonta or Hartwick?

I lived in Cooperstown from age 10 through High School graduation. Playing all your home games on Double Day field from age 13 on isn't a bad perk.
EggRocket said…
I went to Cooperstown in 1987 and finally made it back there this fall. My wife surprised me with a membership to the Hall (i KNOW). We rented a cabin a few miles north on the lake. Here's a few photos of the Hall and the town and the area:!i=2146174357&k=PsDxz98

I certainly am jealous of anybody who can make this a day trip.

BTW...I really liked the HOF cards until you pointed out all the bumped heads. Now that's all I can see. Curse you Night Owl.
Anonymous said…
That really looks like a Texas Rangers LOGO on the Nolan Ryan Hall of Fame Plaque! Lawsuit forthcoming?!?!?!

I've been to Cooperstown twice. I can't believe I only made it up there once during the 2.5 years I lived in Northern NJ. You're right, everyone out their should enjoy the day-tripping while they can...

Popular posts from this blog

That was easy

   My approach on 2021 Topps, after seeing the cards, empty shelves and the tales of inflated prices, was that I could last the entire year without buying any.   The effort wasn't worth it. I'll just take my Dodgers and go home.   I went to Target once after the release date a couple weeks ago, I don't really remember what day I went, and saw empty shelves and shrugged.   So, move forward two weeks and it's birthday season. Those who have read this blog for awhile know I have a lot of birthdays in my family in March and it's the primary shopping time of the year, besides Christmas. I went to Target yesterday for a few items and I made sure to check the card aisle, just in case. I didn't expect to find anything, but I think you know me by now, I have to buy my first packs of the season if I have the opportunity. It's worth a look. The shelves seemed fairly empty as I approached. But they weren't. When I got there, I saw maybe six or seven 2021 Topps baseb

Reliving my childhood isn't easy

  My favorite part of collecting cards doesn't have to do with collecting current players, rookie cards or prospecting.   Although I pay attention to and buy modern cards and also seek out cards from before I was collecting or even before I was born, none of those cards are why I'm doing this.   The best part of collecting for me -- where the warm fuzzies reside, what I'd save for myself after chucking the rest of my collection -- is any card that was released when I was a child or young teen. I don't think I'm special in that way. A lot of collectors probably feel that way. But, unlike, say, the adult who grew up during the junk wax era, who can open pack after pack of 1990 Donruss and get that nostalgic rush without fear of packs ever disappearing, it's a little more difficult for me. I can go to a discount store a couple of miles away in town and grab some 1988 Donruss packs (I think I can still do that, who knows with the hobby weirdness lately). But there&#

G.O.A.T, the '80s: 20-11

  Big news at the night owl nest today. I subscribed to MLB.TV. Finally, I can watch any game I want this season. I no longer have to suffer with seeing the Mets play the Marlins for the 197th time or grit my teeth through Michael Kay because there's no baseball to watch anywhere else. I can ignore the Yankees for 162 games if I want! And that's what I plan to do. The Phillies-Orioles spring training game is on right now and then I'll search out something even more obscure later. I know, I know, I'm late to the party. That's the way it's been when it comes to entertainment viewing for most of my life. Taking years to land an MLB subscription was more of a cash-flow issue, but when I was younger, I'd miss out on the popular movies all the time because of a relatively sheltered existence. While high school classmates were quoting lines from Caddyshack and Stripes in the lunch room and on the school bus, I knew mostly Star Wars movies and E.T. HBO was the big t