This post was inspired by a night owl-specific prompt from one of the original card bloggers, Phungo, the other day:
If I'm correct in knowing what he means, I have mentioned this aspect of the 1975 Topps set in passing a number of times on this blog and especially when I was writing the 1975 Topps blog.
But I haven't written an entire post on it, covering every team included in the set.
As you know, the '75 set has wild two-tone borders with colors that clash crazily with the team featured -- what team wears purple-and-green that isn't the NBA's Milwaukee Bucks in the 1990s? But there are instances in which the colors match almost perfectly. Those are the times when you wondered if Topps specifically picked those borders to honor that player, and those were also the times when that card would often become a favorite of mine when I was collecting the set as a kid.
Here now is what I found as the perfect color match for each team in the '75 set:
ATLANTA BRAVES - Darrell Evans
The "best" color combo among the Braves cards in the light-blue/green combo (called the "day baseball color combo on my '75 blog) with the red letters. There are four Braves with this combo, including two others featuring the same uniform combo as Evans and with red stands in the background. But Evans' bat pose is the clincher for me.
BALTIMORE ORIOLES - Jim Palmer
It's a toss-up between Palmer and Bob Grich, also with the orange/brown combo. Palmer jumped out at me in 1975, so that's what I picked.
BOSTON RED SOX - Rick Burleson
One of the tougher teams to match up. The best border combo for the Red Sox (like a number of teams) would be the red-blue combo, but it's not used with any Red Sox player.
One of the cards where I wonder if Topps specifically selected this color combo for Tanana. The only yellow visible on Tanana's uniform is the halo on the logo on his left sleeve, but you know there's other halos on that uniform. The red and the blue work, too, even if the blue isn't perfect.
One of my favorite under-the-radar perfect matches. The light blue matches with the blue shown in the photo and the peach border is a neutral color that accents the red team name that matches with the Cubs logo on the jersey and hat.
CHICAGO WHITE SOX - Wilbur Wood
The White Sox were wearing their baby blue jerseys at the time with the red lettering, so this matches pretty well.
There are four Reds cards with the red-yellow border combo. Three of them are wearing Reds warm-up jackets for extra "redness." I went with McEnaney because of all the yellowish infield dirt behind him.
CLEVELAND INDIANS - George Hendrick
The Indians wore a darker blue than the border used but there are no navy blue borders in '75 Topps. This works great though. I've always liked this card.
DETROIT TIGERS - Woodie Fryman
The Tigers aren't the most vibrantly-colored team but the touches of orange in Fryman's uniform work well with this combo (aka, the HoJo color combo).
HOUSTON ASTROS - Larry Milbourne
A bit like the Frank Tanana card, although there is no yellow in the uniform. It just works a little bit better than some of the other candidates (Mike Cosgrove, JR Richard, Roger Metzger).
No natural matches, so I narrowed in on the cards with the baby blue border on the bottom. Frank White works the best, again because of all the infield dirt.
LOS ANGELES DODGERS - Manny Mota
I've known for a long time that the color combos used with the Dodgers in '75 weren't matching. Two that would have been key candidates -- the red & blue used with Jim Brewer and Geoff Zahn pretty much hide the key aspect, the Dodgers' red number on the front. Mota doesn't hide his number, so it matches with the team name, and the blue works with the uniform and the top of the photo and the green with the bottom.
MILWAUKEE BREWERS - Ken Berry
The yellow/light blue combo is ideal for the Brewers of this time period. Berry isn't the only Brewer featured on this combo (Tom Murphy, Eduardo Rodriguez), but I like this one the best.
MINNESOTA TWINS - Bert Blyleven
Do you think the bubble gum and the dungeon-dugout setting are the only reasons why I like this card? The border combo with Blyleven's uniform is killer.
Tough not to choose the Chuck Taylor card, but the fact that Singleton is close-up and Taylor is not made me choose Singleton.
NEW YORK METS - Don Hahn
This combo is too perfect for someone named Don Hahn (no Seaver, no Koosman?) but that's the random wonderfulness of 1975 Topps.
OAKLAND ATHLETICS - Claudell Washington
So many options with the A's, who were not-so-coincidentally the defending World Series champions. You could go with yellow-green, like with Pat Bourque at the top of the post or Joe Rudi, you could go all green, like with Catfish Hunter or Ken Holtzman, or you could go with Sal Bando, who has the same color combo as Washington. But Bando didn't have the cup ...
PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES - Greg Luzinski
Not a ton of matches with the Phillies but this works nicely.
Probably the toughest team to match. Topps did not want to put yellow with many of the Pirates cards. Half the players on the team have green borders! Taveras is one of the few featuring yellow.
SAN DIEGO PADRES - Fred Kendall
This works better than the Gene Locklear card, which uses the same color combo but Locklear's in airbrushed mode.
SAN FRANCISCO GIANTS - John D'Acquisto
One of the cards that I noticed matching as a kid. This card and the Dave Kingman card are kind of a toss-up, but D'Acquisto is showing more orange on his jersey.
ST. LOUIS CARDINALS - Bob Gibson
I've said this before: don't tell me that this color combo was a coincidence. On Gibson's final card? No way.
TEXAS RANGERS - Steve Foucault
In 1975, I had little idea about the teams in MLB. I knew to root for the Dodgers. I couldn't tell you about the other teams, except maybe the Reds, or many of the players. All you needed at that time was facial hair and a matching color border to become a favorite.
So, there you are, the perfect matches for each team in 1975 Topps.
Yeah, I know, I didn't show the Yankees.
That's because the Yankees wear noncolors. They claim they wear navy blue, but it looks black and the rest of the jersey is white. The uniform actually allows it to work well with every color combo in the '75 set and why pink-and-yellow is jarring with any other team but not the Yankees. But I couldn't find a true match for them.
All right, now you know. And another 1975 Topps post down in the record books.
Comments
Great cards picked, and happy to see a bunch of Rookie Cups in there.
B. Just saw that Gibson in a YT video and decided I want one for my vintage binder. The guy commented how much he liked how the card colors paired with the Cardinals colors.
C. Saw your comment on Bo's post. If you're building a 75 Mini set, email me a list or link with your needs and I'll try to help you out.
I loved the rookie trophy add on too. Had he not come up mid season, Ron Leflore would have likely gotten a trophy.
Your claudell Washington card is nicely centered, which is rare for him. Same for Tanana. Mine are diamond cut. I'm not going to pay a lot for psa graded centered cards of those two just because.
The Carter rookie included two Tigers who came up to the bigs with high expectations, Danny Meyer and Leon Robert's, but both ended up on Seattle after expansion.
This was also the set that started and ended with Hank Aaron plus included the last Al Kaline card (highlights). You just can't beat the first five cards of the set. Highlights of Aaron, Brock, Gibson, Kaline, and Ryan. That's a great OF tandem and two blazers on the mound!
I completed the '75 mini set almost nine years ago:
https://nightowlcards.blogspot.com/2014/12/minnnnniiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii.html
But I like the idea of having extra '75 minis around. It's only my all-time favorite set.