Skip to main content

The world's biggest checklist fan

 
I am about the only card blogger that I can think of who has multiple blog posts dedicated to old-school checklists.

All those posts were generated by nostalgia, pure and simple. I cannot reasonably expect those checklists to return to current sets nor pretend that I enjoyed pulling them out of packs way back then.

But the look of them -- the very '70s look of them -- I do enjoy and they make me smile, as ugly as they are.
 
I can respect them for the purpose that they served at the time -- it was the only way to track your collection. The checklists in current flagship show up on the back of random action/celebration shots. Those cards have no purpose -- front or back -- and need to go. If you're going to placate a few old-school collectors by including checklist boxes on the back, make the fronts themed, something like notable highlights from the past year seems easy enough.
 
Anyway, due to the current treatment of checklists and recognizing that nobody needs to be pulling a checklist out of a pack today, I had moved on from longing for checklists. This is probably my most recent post on them. But I was over them then and am now.

Until this popped up:


The very second I saw this I felt like the world's biggest checklist fan. I took one glance at the price and immediately clicked "buy". Holy smokes, I've never wanted a checklist so bad.

Perhaps you don't realize what this mean.

This is a milestone moment. This is the first time in nearly 10 years of chasing that I have seen a buyback checklist from the 1975 Topps set. I've accumulated 500-plus cards from the '75 set in buyback form, but until now I did not own -- nor ever see -- one of the checklists.

Landing this card makes it feel like anything is possible in getting the rest of the buyback cards in the set, though I know realistically that's not the case. I landed another '75 buyback at the same time as the checklist. That one has yet to arrive but when it does I will have acquired 525 of the 660 cards in buyback form. That officially rounds up to 80 percent of the set!

And it took a little checklist to get there. Even after all these years I'm relying on checklist cards to complete a set.

Comments

And it is unmarked, ever better.
Old Cards said…
Glad to see you reached this point in your collection. You pinpointed the great collecting conundrum of the 70's and the 60's - not wanting to pull checklist cards out of packs, but knowing you needed them!
Jeremya1um said…
If you found 1 checklist buyback in the wild, that means the other (I’m assuming 5) are out there as well. Good luck.
Congratulations!

If you gave me a choice in 2025 Heritage between honest-to-goodness checklist cards or some junk insert featuring - let's say - Marcell Ozuna, I might have to go Checklist. 1976 had the (arguably) nicest checklist of the 1970s (FWIW)
Nick Vossbrink said…
Oh wow. The only cards I could reliably pull as a kid were checklists. Always felt like being cheated out of a card back then. Now I'm confused why they weren't treated like the various advertising cards (whether for mail-in sets, a spring training drawing, topps company store, etc) that were also always in packs.

Anyway, Congrats on a milestone for the buyback set. I'm surprised I didn't pull a REDISCOVER TOPPS buyback CL back when those were a thing.
gregory said…
Nicely done, sir. I've got to say, as time has gone on, I do appreciate a good vintage checklist more and more.
OhioTim said…
Great looking checklist buyback card! Do you only collect checklist cards from baseball? Keep showing your appreciation for checklist cards! I love to read and talk to others about their unique collections.
Fuji said…
Congratulations on nabbing this card and reaching the 80% mark on this set build. Never stopped to think about buyback checklists... but now that I have... I don't think I've seen any.
Bo said…
Angels in Order might want to fight you for that title.
Grant said…
It's too bad the checklist buy-backs aren't more prevalent. If they were then you could use them like they were intended on your buy-back set journey!
POISON75 said…
Mr Owl only you & I can as well any set builder can see Greatness in Checklists cards congrats on the latest pick up
Michael D said…
Nice pick up. I think its cool that your working on the buyback set. 80% is amazing! What a great challenge that is. Good Luck on the rest.
John Bateman said…
The fun of the checklist is just seeing all the names. The 50th anniversary logo just below Willie McCovey's name - classic