Skip to main content

Somehow I'm still doing this

 
I know, or have come across, several fans my age or older who are no longer interested in major league baseball as it's played now.

I've also read or written a good number of profiles on former players who say they don't watch the game anymore. It just doesn't look like the game they know and played.

Whether you think that is a closed-minded way of thinking or a natural reaction as people grow older, it's very apparent to me that those who play MLB now are different than the players who played in the '70s, '80s and even much of the '90s when I was younger and much more of a fan.

Just about every day -- especially now that it's the postseason -- the difference hits me in the face. As I'm scrolling through the limited number of photos available (a rant for another time) to use when I'm producing the sports section for my paper, I regularly see players screaming into the air as if they had just smote the enemy on a bloody battlefield. It strikes me instinctively as over the top. I can't even imagine being able to unleash that type of emotion ... for anything.

I don't think I ever saw a player do that, even in the World Series, throughout the '70s and '80s. A little bat flip? Sure. An instinctive leap or clap or "Yeah!"? OK. Piling on each other after the last out of the Series? You bet. But full-throated roars after your team turned a double play in the sixth inning of the ALDS? Yikes. Did Tiger Woods start all this?

There is a lot about the current game that I don't get/can't relate to/don't understand, and it shows itself most in the postseason. The Padres may be example A of modern-day baseball behavior though every team has it. There's too much drama and not enough baseball for my taste.

I also could go on about the 14 levels of playoffs, the domination of wild-card teams, the inability of any pitcher to last more than four innings, the gesturing every time someone gets on base, etc.

So why do I still watch? Why do I still collect?
 
Finally getting to the card at the top of the post, this Shota Imanaga card -- in the shopped jersey -- arrived from The Shlabotnik Report. It was the final card I needed to complete the 2024 Topps flagship set (Yeah, there's that second Shohei Ohtani card needed, but I just ordered one!)
 
For the first time since 2015, I have completed more than one set in the year in which it was issued. In 2015, I completed 2015 flagship and the Traded set as well as 2015 Stadium Club. This year I've completed flagship and 2024 Heritage. That's a very modern thing to do.
 
All of these cards contain players that play a game that I don't understand in a lot of ways. But I'm still here watching and collecting.
 
I still collect modern sets because I still find designs and card sets that interest me. They don't show up as often -- therefore nine years between doing this -- but you come up with a nice design and put ballplayers on it, then I'm interested. 

Also I've been able to do a good job of compartmentalizing when collecting and watching. I doubt I will ever be one of those older guys who just stops watching. I don't want to cut myself off from something that I still enjoy a lot. I'm still amazed by things that current players do -- Ohtani for example. And the actual plays in the field and much of the hitting remains the same. Let's just say there's enough for me to root for and root against, so the emotion and interest is still there.

I've addressed all of this in previous posts, but with the playoffs how they've been, I did look at the Imanaga card and scratch my head a little.

Will there be another year in which I finish two modern sets? I don't know. I suppose it depends on how many cards of players screaming are in the set (there are already too many).

Comments

Old Cards said…
Agree. Over-the-top on-field celebrations are over done. Showing some humility and some self control would be nice? Maybe instead of celebrating, let the roar of the crowd and the encouragement of your teammates be sufficient.
Who knows maybe MLB will impose an automatic man on third rule for excessive celebrations. LOL
DoubleBrook said…
The real question is why the screaming celebrations make up as many card images as they do. Okay, he's a tough competitor giving it 110%. We get it. We could definitely do with more class in photos.
Nick Vossbrink said…
Have never been a fan of the big celebration since baseball is one of those games that has a way of biting you in the ass. In my memory Eckersley is the first player I think of doing this regularly. I can't help but wonder if the increased single-inning pitcher usage has fueled a lot of it.
Fuji said…
Excessive celebrations aren't just a baseball problem. It happens in football a lot too. That being said... the NFL penalizes players depending on the situation. Maybe one day that'll happen in baseball too.
carlsonjok said…
I am not bothered by celebrations. I always found the enforced stoicism to be silly. My one issue, similar to you, is the revolving door of pitchers during the game. I understand it as good pitching is a rare commodity and I think the modern game is more stressful on arms. But, I don't like it to the extent it lengthens the game significantly. To that end, I applaud efforts like the pitch clock and a minimum batters faced for relief pitchers that bring the games back to a reasonable length of time.
GCA said…
Football came to mind for me too. Guys are celebrating making a tackle after a short gain. Dude, that's your job, not an amazing accomplishment. Don't work on "promoting your brand" in the SportsCenter highlights until you actually accomplish something significant.
Bo said…
Pascual Perez was another trailblazer in this area.
Ginko-5 said…
Honestly....yeah, the celebrations are a bit much. Tatis and Profar seem to be the main culprits.... I don't quite like all the rule changes either, and think that they may be cause for the higher rate of injuries happening in the game. I may or may not go on a big rant on my blog about all these in the off-season.

I find it interesting that the Tigers have one starting pitcher, and three bullpen games in their starting rotation. It's rather annoying that you don't see too many pitcher's duals because for most every team it's all bullpen.
Mightymango360v said…
The over the top reactions are annoying. It is almost like they are pandering to photographers to take the picture for baseball cards. Look at the 2024 Series 1 box/wrapper picture. Acuna losing his MIND over something. Look at the 2021 Series 2. It is almost like step one after doing something "amazing" is to knock off the helmet and then step 2 is scream!

Also MLB baseball, analytics, or whatever has made starting pitches like running backs are in the NFL. (disposable)
They don't let them work through problems and let some math equation that removes the human element make the choice.

I know oldish guy yelling at clouds but the game in its roots right now is not as good as it used to be. That said It isn't all bad, the pitch clock and other limiters have speed the game up which is great.
This post and the comments make me feel better, I felt like I must be the only one who can't relate to the celebratory shouting. A few years ago my bowling team won a big game, my one teammate insisted that we chest bump and I couldn't do it without laughing at how NOT ME it was, so I guess I'm not the proper demographic for this type of thing.
Anonymous said…
I think it's partly the unfortunate influence pro wrestling has had on sports entertainment.
Nick said…
I do find people who stopped watching baseball *exclusively* because of the over-the-top celebrations and such a bit closed-minded. You're gonna tell me you missed out on seeing someone like Shohei Ohtani because people yell a little too much for your taste? Seems like a bad trade-off to me.

I'm by no means a huge fan of dudes standing at home plate watching home runs for twenty seconds, but at the end of the day, baseball is still baseball, and I love it.
Jafronius said…
My kid struck someone out a year or so ago and was doing the yelling into his glove bit going back into the dugout. Had to ask him what that was all about after the game (they lost). Just excited, that's all was what he said. I said your job was to get out of the inning, you weren't pitching for a championship. He stopped doing that for a while.

Congrats on the completed sets!