Skip to main content

The terrific 10

Once upon a time I was all about the postseason awards. I couldn't wait to see who won the MVP award or the Cy Young. I remember reading in the newspaper about Rod Carew winning the American League MVP in 1977 and George Foster winning the National League MVP. It was a big deal, a moment big in my brain.

But these days I've kind of lost touch with the baseball awards. I think it doesn't help that baseball has delayed them a full week from when they used to announce them. It also doesn't help when they announce "the top three candidates" ahead of time so you already know who the top three are. Kind of takes some of the suspense away.

But overall I think it's because I just don't care too much about present-day ballplayers. And awards are very individualistic. It's a vehicle for the hype machine and we have to hear again about how Mike Trout is the greatest baseball specimen who ever walked the earth.

However, I still have that little kid in me who read about the MVPs in the newspaper. I'm not one of those people who thinks awards are stupid and that we should do away with them. I think awards serve a purpose, and for people who aren't narcissists, it's nice to get validation from someone outside of yourself.

So, when Cody Bellinger won the NL MVP award yesterday, I was a bit happy about that, and not just because it gave me an excuse to show the above very weird but also very pretty 2018 Panini Chronicles card, sent to me by Sports Cards From The Dollar Store (more cards from him in a later post).

Bellinger happens to be the 10th Dodgers player to win the MVP award.

Yup, that's it. Just 10. Almost 90 years of announcing the Most Valuable Player -- in the modern era anyway -- and they're just hitting double-digits.

The Dodgers have actually won the MVP award 12 times. Roy Campanella won the honor three times in his career.

That places the Dodgers tied for third overall among total NL MVP awards. The Cardinals lead by far with 17 NL MVPs, followed by the Giants with 13. The Dodgers are tied with the Reds with 12.

I think this is why I didn't know where the Dodgers stood in MVP awards until I wrote this post. They don't rule the award like they do with the Cy Young Award or Rookie of the Year Award.

The Dodgers are easily the leaders in the ROY award with 18. They also are in control of the Cy Young Award with 11 overall. (It's interesting to see what teams don't care about pitching with these honors. The Reds, who have been around forever, have somehow never fielded a Cy Young Award winner).

I'll put the NL totals for all three awards at the end of this post just because maybe somebody besides me will find it interesting. But meanwhile, I'd like to recognize The Terrific 10, those Dodgers who have won the MVP award.

2019: Cody Bellinger beat out Christian Yelich and Anthony Rendon for the award. It's not full payback for Ryan Braun stealing the award from Matt Kemp in 2011, but yesterday's announcement did make me feel a little better about things.

Also, I'm listing the player who finished fourth in each vote because that person now gets shafted with this "Top 3" nonsense. Fourth place in 2019 NL MVP voting went to the Diamondbacks' Ketel Marte.

2014: Clayton Kershaw won over the Marlins' Giancarlo Stanton and the Pirates' Andrew McCutchen. Despite some people thinking pitchers shouldn't win the MVP, Dodgers pitchers have won their share.

Fourth-place finisher: the Brewers' Jonathan Lucroy.

1988: Kirk Gibson won the NL MVP award over the Mets' Darryl Strawberry and Kevin McReynolds, which I think is hilarious because the Mets also lost to the Dodgers in the NLCS. DODGERS ARE CHAMPS ALL AROUND!

Fourth-place finisher: the Pirates' Andy Van Slyke

1974: Steve Garvey captured the MVP over Lou Brock and fellow Dodger Mike Marshall. The Dodgers' Jimmy Wynn finished fifth to give the team three players in the top five.

Fourth-place finisher: the Reds' Johnny Bench

1963: Sandy Koufax's commanding '63 season gave him the MVP award over Dick Groat and Hank Aaron and the Dodgers back-to-back MVP awards for the second time in their history.

Fourth-place finisher: the Dodgers' Ron Perranoski

1962: Maury Wills captured the MVP award in an insanely close finish with Willie Mays as they were separated by just seven vote points. The Dodgers' Tommy Davis was third.

Fourth-place finisher: the Reds' Frank Robinson

1956: In what's got to be the only time this has happened, Don Newcombe won the NL MVP over fellow Dodgers pitcher Sal Maglie. Two pitchers on the same team finishing 1-2 for the MVP award? Hank Aaron took third.

Fourth-place finisher: the Braves' Warren Spahn

1955: Roy Campanella won his third MVP award by a mere five vote points over teammate Duke Snider. Ernie Banks was third and Willie Mays fourth.

1953: Roy Campanella beat out Eddie Mathews and Duke Snider for the award. Red Schoendienst placed fourth.

1951: Roy Campanella finished ahead of Stan Musial and Monte Irvin. Sal Maglie was fourth.

1949: Jackie Robinson won the MVP award just two years after breaking the color barrier, ahead of Cardinals Stan Musial and Enos Slaughter.

Fourth-place finisher: the Pirates' Ralph Kiner

1941: Dolph Camilli  topped a Dodgers' trifecta as Pete Reiser was second and Whit Wyatt third. The Cardinals' Jimmy Brown finished fourth.

And that's your 10 Dodgers MVPs.

If you go back before the Baseball Writers Association got involved in selecting MVPs, you could add Dazzy Vance (1924) and Jake Daubert (1913) to the Dodgers totals. But there were a whole mess of years before 1931 in which no MVP was selected, which I'm sure makes the Anti-Award people happy.

But without awards people like me could not do obsessive breakdowns like this.

So here's the team rundown for the three big NL awards over the years:


Cardinals 17, Giants 13, Dodgers 12, Reds 12, Cubs 9, Phillies 8, Pirates 7, Braves 6, Brewers 2, Astros 1, Marlins 1, Nationals 1, Padres 1, Rockies 1

No MVPs: Diamondbacks, Mets

Cy Young Award

Dodgers 11, Braves 7, Mets 7, Phillies 6, Cubs 5, Diamondbacks 5, Padres 4, Cardinals 3, Giants 3, Astros 2, Nationals 2, Pirates 2, Expos 1

No Cy Youngs: Brewers, Marlins, Reds, Rockies

Rookie of the Year

Dodgers 18, Braves 9, Reds 7, Cardinals 6, Giants 6, Mets 6, Cubs 5, Marlins 4, Phillies 4, Expos 2, Padres 2, Astros 1, Brewers 1, Nationals 1, Pirates 1, Rockies 1


Glen said…
Pretty sure two Brewers have won MVP's: Braun and Yelich.
Some of those numbers are surprising, but most are not. It would take at least ten years a full decade or better for some team (my team) to pass your Dodgers on the ROY, and even then they'd have to win 10 consecutive years. OUCH.
Brett Alan said…
Actually, the Brewers have won 5 MVP awards, but you're right that they've won 2 *NL* MVP awards, which is what's being listed here.

As a Mets fan, I do enjoy the whining about how NO's team has "only" had 10 different MVP winners. But I guess having just taken the other two major player awards I can't really complain. B^)
Jeremya1um said…
I could’ve swore Piazza won an MVP.
Section 36 said…
I hate being reminded that Kershaw won in 2014 because it just reminds me how absolutely screwed Pedro got when he didn't win in 1999.
EddieK said…
The Brewers won 2 Cy Young Awards, but when they were still in the AL.
night owl said…
I'd like to say I'm keeping it at 1 to protest Braun's selection. Also, I'm not whining, I was just a little surprised that it wasn't more given how long they've been around.

Also, all this Brewers confusion just underlines Selig's stupid move.
Matt said…
The fact he was left off one voter's ballot entirely still pisses me off!
Chris said…
I enjoyed this post. So many interesting facts I hadn't realized. (Campy has three MVPs? The Mets haven't had any?) Adding 4th place finishers was a nice touch. I agree with disavowing Braun's MVP award, and the Pedro comment by Section 36.

Also, I just posted a Reds' All-Time Team and I was shocked at how lousy their pitching history has been over 100+ years. They do have a lot of MVPs though - including a pre-war pitcher.
sg488 said…
Great breakdown, maybe in the future you could breakdown the American League.
Fuji said…
The Dodgers definitely dominate when it comes to NL Awards. But that doesn't surprise me. The Cardinals winning 17 MVP's does though. I'm off to see how many different players make up these 17. Gotta imagine Musial and Pujols make up a good portion of them.
Fuji said…
Just in case you're curious... both guys won 3 (Musial: 1943, 1946, and 1948) (Pujols: 2005, 2008, and 2009). I'm actually surprised that Pujols didn't win more.
"...I just don't care too much about present day ballplayers..."

CinciCuse Bill said…
In relative modern times, the Reds have had three 2nd place CY finishers, only to have lost each time to a member of your Dodgers. J. Cueto lost out to Kershaw in 14, Danny Jackson had am AMAZING season in 88 only to loose to an even more AMAZING season by Hershiser, and Tom Terrific lost out to Fernandomania in 81. Enough already! :)
bbcardz said…
Another awesome post featuring my Dodgers! I'm so happy that Belli won the MVP award and so disappointed that Hyun-Jin Ryu didn't win the Cy Young Award. If I was a betting man, I'd go all in on the Dodgers adding another ROY in 2020.
Jason T. Carter said…
The Reds have never had a Cy Young winner but have been runners-up 5 times. Twice beat out by Dodgers if memory serves.

JT, The Writer's Journey
Jason T. Carter said…
Didn't read other responses before I posted. Three Dodgers toppling my Reds. Grrrr.

CinciCuse Bill mentioned Seaver, Danny Jackson, and Cueto. The other two bridesmaids were Mario Soto and Pete Schourek. Pete Schourek?!?!?!?!

Popular posts from this blog

BIG numbers

This is one of those milestone things that used to mean a lot more.Back in my first year or two of blogging, I'd note the milestones that passed and really celebrate them as if they were a big deal. And they really did seem like a big deal at the time:300th post. Wooo!400th post. Weee!500th post. Well that was kind of lame.900th post. You could tell I was already getting sick of coming up with milestone post ideas.But I still like celebrating milestones, no matter what form they take. Not only does it satisfy my compulsion to categorize with numbers, but a nice, big, round number is proof that you've been doing something for awhile -- and if it's worth keeping track of, then probably that thing you've been doing for awhile is enjoyable.So even though I don't flip out quite as much over blog milestones, I've reached yet another one and here I am mentioning it.
I've surpassed 3 million views, you guys.Just once I'd like to witness the odometer turning over…

Card stuff I discovered on the internet

This post was originally going to be called "stuff I discovered on the internet," but I figured that would leave too much to the imagination.Before the internet came along, I discovered cards and card sets mostly through advertisements in the Sporting News or Baseball Digest, or through hobby catalogs that came to my house, like TCMA or Fritsch Cards. Later, I subscribed to Baseball Cards Magazine and found new-to-me sets in articles in that magazine.But I missed so much through those methods. Outside of what was selling in wax or cello packs at the drug or grocery store, that was all I knew.It wasn't until years and years later, when I ended up online like everyone else, that I discovered how much that I had missed.Once I became aware of card blogs, the door was open wider than ever. There were so many sets -- so many sets and cards that often had been issued right under my nose -- that I never knew existed.For example:
I had no idea there were so many box sets from Flee…

Overwhelmed then underwhelmed

Well, welcome back card aisle, you're looking rather ... uh ... disorderly.This was the sight at my neighborhood Target yesterday. As disorganized and scattered as it appears, I can count three different baseball card products (four, if you add the MLB stickers) in just this small crop of the card aisle.This is as many different kinds of baseball card products that I've seen on area store shelves since March. With Covid quarantining and the inexplicable ransacking of card shelves across the country, I've purchased almost no cards in person for the last six months. (On Twitter I mentioned these were the first 2020 baseball cards I had seen on shelves since March, which isn't quite true. I forgot I picked up a couple of scattered packs of Series two a couple of months ago. That's how forgettable Topps flagship is this year).Within that frame are a couple of hanger boxes of 2020 Topps Fire, a half-filled gravity feeder of 2020 Stadium Club and, up at the top, a gravit…