Skip to main content

All that yelling

 
I posted this card on my 1993 Upper Deck blog yesterday. If you're in the habit of reading that blog maybe you missed it as blogger just got around to getting it on the reader list nearly a day after I uploaded it.
 
When I wrote it, I noted that the shot of Navarro yelling was a precursor to the cards of today, in which it seems there's a guy shouting in every pack. And just to be sure, I checked the 1993 UD cards I've already posted and at card No. 237, it's the first yelling shot in the set.
 
I didn't check the rest of the set but I'd be surprised if there are more than five cards of guys shouting in the set. It's definitely a more modern thing.
 
As someone who grew up in the '70s and also someone who recoils at the thought of drawing attention to myself, the performative yelling that pro athletes do is still foreign and unnecessary to me. I'm a quiet guy, mostly, who doesn't mind sitting by myself in the quiet -- in fact, I prefer it. I also get annoyed by the growing noise in society. I'm a writer by profession, they generally are more productive in the quiet.
 
So, all that yelling, yeah, I don't get it.
 
For comparison's sake, I found the most recent Topps set I've completed, which is from 2024, and pulled all the yellers. I found 26 of them and probably missed a couple.
  

What are the reasons for all this yelling on cards nowadays?
 
Does it make for interesting photos? Sure, I guess. But I notice plenty of yelling when watching games so Topps isn't necessarily isolating it.
 
Is it the Tiger Woods effect, as I've heard someone call it? When Woods was emoting on the golf course back in the late 1990s it was definitely different.
 
Is it current society's treatment of athletes as celebrities rather than the guys playing ball? 
 
Is it the higher stakes of the current game? A lot more money is involved and it seems players' careers are more on the line than in the past. In previous years, teams were more willing to not upset the status quo. Now, teams are perpetually transacting. The business aspect is much more visible than the "let's play two" aspect.
 
Is it because baseball is more multi-cultural than in the past? Sure, that's got to be a factor. We white dudes of North European stock are known to keep our feelings "bottled up".
 
I don't think of it that way though. I think I'm just a chill guy, that's what people tell me anyway and some happen to find it attractive. You'd have to get me to a therapist to find out whether I'm suppressing, but I don't think any amount of therapy will get me to scream "COME ON" on a ball field. It's just not me.
 
But, generally, I've gotten used to it. It's so pervasive in the current game.
 
 

In fact, I find Alex Vesia -- who might be the most animated player in all of baseball -- amusing. He's almost like a cartoon character with how over the top he is after each out.
 
I would love to look at cards over the last 25 years to see the progression of this phenomenon, but that's not going to happen today and maybe not ever.
 
It just seems like a lot of extra effort. Just like all that yelling.
 

Comments

Zippy Zappy said…
KNICKS WIN! KNICKS WIN! KNICKS WIN!
I wonder when statcast will start to spew out yell-quotient metrics (measured in Oompfs). Baseball cards seems more typecast than ever before and they generally seem to fall in just a few categories. Since we can't have pitchers hitting any longer (unless your surname is Ohtani), I'd really love to see pitchers fielding. Spice it up a bit?
Old Cards said…
I'm in agreement with you on the yelling and the growing noise in society. I grew up in a quiet family, so I am quiet as well. I don't think quiet people are bottling up anything. It is just the civilized thing to do. In my opinion, the yelling on cards is an outgrowth of the ridiculous overt celebrating on what seems like every play. Growing up in the 60's, I watched players hit a homerun or make a great play and then tuck their heads down and trot back to the dugout. They had class. I miss it.
Laurens said…
I think the modern game is buttoned down and stuffy as far as the personalities and make up of the the redass, keep your down guys who play the game, so I appreciate those who occasionally show the heat of the moment emotion.
Nick Vossbrink said…
For a game where failure is so common I can see why doing well might be cause for an emotional release. At the same time, I'm one of those guys who thinks that yelling like that is just asking to be mocked the many many times you fail.
night owl said…
I think there's a healthy middle ground between the 'act like you've been there before" unspoken rules and the screaming after every pitched strikeout.
Angus said…
I sometimes roll my eyes at the yelling since I think it happens too often at plays that aren't that important. I don't mind the odd yell after an important play.

Now, as a fan, I do a lot of yelling when I watch the Browns or Mets. A lot of "No!!!", and "Why would you do that?" Sometimes I wonder why I watch.
Matt said…
Topps needs to bring back manager cards so we can have pictures of them yelling.
Damien said…
I think a lot of the yelling is an attempt to gain and hold attention, which is harder to get nowadays largely due to the effects of screens. Back in the day the play itself was enough to get attention; modern players need attention just the same but need to go further to get it. It's become so habitual in our culture that it's done subconsciously.

I do agree that humility, meekness, and quietness (not "acting little," just not "acting big") is a mark of civility, manners, and our human rationality.
Ginko-5 said…
I've started a mini-collection on Don Cardwell, similarly called 'The Mouth Agape PC.' I've only referenced it a couple times though
Fuji said…
One of the YouTubers I enjoy following calls these "burps"... and he points them out whenever he opens up packs. That's how I noticed they've become more prevalent in recent years.