Skip to main content

The underdog

 
I tell ya, clearing snow on a daily basis is not only a lot of work but it's very time-consuming. Where's night owl been? Outside trying to put snow on top of snowbanks taller than me, that's where.
 
So, I don't have a lot here, just some self-examination.
 
I was thinking a few weeks ago about my favorite players when I was a kid. You know some of them. For instance, Ron Cey. He was probably a lot of fans' favorites, but he didn't have nearly as many fans as his teammate, Steve Garvey. Cey was the underdog. I gravitated toward him, probably partly because he wasn't Steve Garvey.
 
My interest in the underdog was even more pronounced when it came to the Dodgers' pitching staff from that time. My favorite was not Don Sutton. Nor was it Tommy John. It wasn't even No. 3 starter, Burt Hooton. No, it was Doug Rau.
 

I can't really tell you why. I just liked him. I think I liked to attach myself to the lesser-known guy and then urge him on to success -- scolding management in my head, "if you only knew what you had here!" and then "See, I told you!"
 
But I liked the underdog on other teams, too. My favorite Phillies player was not Mike Schmidt or Steve Carlton or Greg Luzinski. It was Garry Maddox. My favorite Red Sox player was not Carl Yastrzemski or even youngsters Fred Lynn and Jim Rice. It was Bernie Carbo and Rick Burleson. My favorite Yankee -- although this is an exceptional case because I couldn't stand most of them -- was Roy White.
 
I thought of myself as an underdog, too. Often overlooked in gym class, I relished surprising the jocks with a well-placed base hit or scoring a goal in floor hockey. Even in college journalism class, it once got back to me that the journalism professor said that the "biggest surprise" in class was me. Don't forget the underdog!
 
My rooting for underdogs continued for a few years, latching on to players like Derrel Thomas and R.J. Reynolds. But around the mid-1980s there was a turning point.
 
I started rooting for an underdog named Orel Hershiser. I didn't know where this guy with the funny came from (turns out he was born in Buffalo and once lived in a home my grandmother lived next to!). But I wanted him to be a star.
  
 
It may surprise some, but Hershiser didn't have a smooth entry into the majors early on, it wasn't even a guarantee that he would be in the rotation. I rooted him on anyway. But then it all clicked. He went 19-3 in 1985 and then he really blew up in 1988. He set a major league record that still stands and became a World Series champion and MVP. He was the most famous player in the majors for a moment. My underdog.
 
All my wishing had worked. Hershiser was now a star. But he wasn't an underdog anymore. And from that point, most of my selections for favorite player on the Dodgers were not underdogs, but stars.
 
Today the team I root for is the exact opposite of being an underdog. The Dodgers are two-time defending World Series champions. The Dodgers have never really been underdogs, except for 1988. You'd have to go back to the 1950s for that (and just because they kept facing the Yankees in the WS). And my current favorite player is the most famous and talented player in the world.
 
I also get a little annoyed when fans instinctively root for the underdog, no matter who it is. I mean I can see rooting for the Pirates, no matter how hapless. But the Rockies? What's that going to do for you? I now tend to admire teams who can perform the best and players who can perform the best. And they sure ain't underdogs.
 
Still ... still, there is something about me that likes the underdog -- on an individual level. As a collector, I like those base cards. Love them. I always want to see them. And I like sets like Topps Total that focused on every player from every team. I also dislike the sound of sets called "Rookies & Stars".
 
That's because I know the value of the underdogs in sport. The No. 8 hitters. The offensive linemen, the backup goalie. Teams cannot function without them. The 1978 Dodgers needed Doug Rau's 15 wins.
 
And even though the Dodgers are a juggernaut, they didn't win without Miguel Rojas or Will Klein.
 
You know what the band says: "You got no fear of the underdog, that's why you will not survive."

Comments

bryan was here said…
That's how it was rooting for the Indians in the 80s. When they started becoming serious contenders again in the 90s, it kind of took the luster off their underdog status. They still revert back to that underdog every so often, like this past season.
Don said…
My first favorite Tiger was Champ Summers. After that I started rooting for Gibby
steelehere said…
I liked Doug Rau as well. He and Burt Hooton were my favorite Dodger starters during that era.

My guess on why Doug Rau may have been a favorite of yours is that he was left-handed just like another favorite of yours from the time, Frank Tanana (when he was a California Angel).
Anonymous said…
That is funny I always liked Doug Rau - maybe it was the way he threw. Maybe because he was the best no 4 starter in the majors. I always thought he had 13-3 2.75 year - his ERA is a little higher than I thought and his Winning Percentage is a little lower than I thought
You know I loved watching under dog as a kid :)
Also if the postal service can manage through the weather, you got a package coming apx. Monday lol.
Nachos Grande said…
The Reds have been an underdog team for my whole life (I missed the juggernauts of the 70s). So yes, I understand the appeal of the underdog (though an underdog that never, ever wins is quite demoralizing and probably foolish to root for).
Zippy Zappy said…
I don't like underdogs, but I do tend to gravitate towards absolutely hapless mediocrity. Big difference.
Angus said…
I think the problem with my Browns is that they're not loveable underdogs, but rather just dogs. I question my sanity for still cheering for them.

As to favorite players, I have many that I would consider to be underdogs, but my all-time favorite is Gary Carter. Not an underdog.
Old Cards said…
Great topic! As a kid in the 60's, I pulled for anybody other than the Yankees, because they won all the time. I pulled for Maris over Mantle in the 1961 homerun race. In the 70's, my favorite player was Jeff Burroughs on the Rangers. In the 80's, as my interest in actually watching MLB began to wane, I definitely liked Orel Hershiser. He was great on the late night TV talk shows. Although extremely talented, he seemed like such a nice down-to-earth guy.
Fuji said…
I've been one of those fans that tends to enjoy rooting for the underdogs, but that usually applies more for teams than specific players. Most of my favorite athletes are stars with a few exceptions like Kurt Suzuki and Byron Scott. But when it comes to collection, I enjoy hoarding everyone... stars and underdogs.