Skip to main content

Dodgers World Series heroes ranked

 

Fair warning: the posts on this blog for the next two or three days are going to be extremely Dodger-centric.

With stakes very high and the first World Series title in 32 years on the line, I need to distribute as many positive Dodger vibes that I can in the the foolhardy belief that it will help. Consider it a blog's version of an athlete wearing the same clothes every day in hopes of bringing some luck.

And if the Dodgers win, I'll need to celebrate with cards as well.

So with that in mind, I started thinking last night about Dodgers World Series heroes of the past. It's no surprise to Dodgers fans that there have been more than a few trials and tribulations for the team during the World Series. The Dodgers have lost more World Series than anyone, their record is 6-14. In total World Series games (including 2020, so far), they are 52-70.

But with that subpar record, they have made enough World Series to produce a good share of Series heroes. They have been around a lot longer than most teams, you know.

Many of the team's World Series heroes are familiar to fans. But I thought I'd rank them in order of greatness. Who were the greatest Dodgers on the World Series stage?

There are two ways you can go with this: you can either treat it cumulatively -- the players with the best WS totals for their career -- or you can focus on memorable moments, what sticks in fans' minds. I decided to combine the two and honor both.

There is nothing scientific here. No numbers or formulas to explain the rankings. This is just feel, from a Dodger fan, with a fondness for history, who knows that the Dodgers are more than "a bazillion-dollar team that buys all their championships," which is a complaint I have to bat down any time the Dodgers get even close to a title.

Here we go:
 

 15. Bob Welch

Dodgers fans will always remember Bob Welch as a 21-year-old rookie who struck out Mr. October, Reggie Jackson, with two on and two out in the ninth inning of Game 2 of the 1978 World Series in an epic confrontation. Welch helped preserve a 4-3 victory and a 2-0 lead in the series for the Dodgers. It all went south for L.A. after that as the Yankees won the next four games and Jackson even homered off of Welch in Game 6. But in that moment, Welch and the Dodgers were on top of the world.
 
 

14. Ron Cey
 
Until the 1981 World Series, The Penguin's postseason exploits were confined to the League Championship Series. That changed in Game 3 against the Yankees when Cey hit a three-run home run off of Dave Righetti and then late in the game dove over the foul line in front of third base to corral Bobby Murcer's pop bunt and then throw to first to double up Larry Milbourne in the eighth inning of a 5-4 game. His performance that game helped spark the Dodgers' comeback from an 0-2 deficit to a World Series title.
 
Cey was beaned by Goose Gossage in Game 5 and had to be helped off the field, but he returned in Game 6 to drive in a run and was named one of three MVPs. He hit .350 that series.
 
 

13. Chuck Essegian
 
Essegian hit a pinch-hit home run for the Dodgers, not once, but twice in the 1959 World Series victory over the White Sox. He hit a two-run home run to tie the game in the seventh inning in a Game 2 victory, evening the series at one game apiece. In the deciding Game 6, he hit a pinch homer in the ninth to set a record, although the Dodgers were ahead 8-3 at that point.
 

12. Cookie Lavagetto
 
I'm embarrassed to admit that I know Cookie Lavagetto only for his no-hitter-busting double in the ninth inning of Game 4 of the 1947 World Series. The hit not only broke up Bill Bevens' attempt to throw the first no-hitter in World Series history but it won the game for the Dodgers, who had trailed 2-1 entering the inning. This was the final hit of Lavagetto's career. Quite a way to go out.
 


11. Max Muncy

The only current player on this list, Max Muncy is here for his 18th-inning home run in Game 3 of the 2018 World Series that ended the most epic Series game I have ever witnessed. My belief that the Dodgers could actually beat the way-too-talented Red Sox was never higher than immediately after Muncy's shot (not that it was ever very high). I still have that game recorded and I should watch it again this offseason.

Muncy is batting .389 this World Series, so if I update this post in a few years, maybe he'll move even higher on the list.


10. Sandy Amoros

Sandy Amoros' claim to fame is one of the most noted World Series events in history. Inserted as a defensive replacement in left field in the ninth inning of a 2-0 Dodgers lead in Game 7 of the 1955 World Series, the Dodgers were trying to win their first championship ever. But the Yankees put their first two batters on base and then Yogi Berra came to the plate. Berra slashed an opposite-field drive to left that appeared to be a sure double as the Dodgers' outfield had shifted to the right. But Amoros covered a tremendous amount of ground and stuck out his glove to nab the ball just before hitting the fence in the left field corner. He threw to the infield and the Dodgers doubled up Gil McDougald for the second out, ending the threat.

Amoros also hit quite well in the '55 World Series, going 4-for-17 with a home run.
 


9. Pedro Guerrero

Pedro Guerrero wasn't very well known to fans outside of Los Angeles when the 1981 postseason began. But by the end of the postseason, hardly a fan didn't know him.

Guerrero hit a home run in Game 5 of the World Series against the Yankees, then was all over the Dodgers' offensive explosion in Game 6. He hit a two-run triple, then hit a two-run single, then a solo home run in the game for five runs batted in, sharing MVP honors with Ron Cey and Steve Yeager. A star was born. He would soon become my favorite player.

By the way, that's an old photo on that 1982 Fleer card. Guerrero is wearing the 1980 All-Star Game patch.
 


8. Mickey Hatcher

Surprise, surprise, the Dodgers can be scrappy with the best of them. The 1988 World Series was expected to pit the A's hitting stars against the Dodgers' pitching prowess. But the Dodgers kept throwing out unexpected contributions from offense from the unlikeliest players.

Mickey Hatcher led them all, hitting two home runs in the World Series, each time giving the Dodgers the lead that it wouldn't surrender. Hatcher had hit one home run the entire regular season.



7. Lou Johnson

Another surprising showing. The recently departed Lou Johnson joined the Dodgers after star outfielder Tommy Davis was lost for the season in May of 1965 due to a broken ankle. Johnson hit two home runs in the 1965 World Series against the Twins. His home run in Game 7 proved to be the game-winner.
 
 

6. Duke Snider
 
While the Yankees were beating up on the Dodgers all those World Series in the 1950s, Duke Snider kept slugging away. He hit above .300 in the 1952, 1953, 1955 and 1956 World Series. And he hit four home runs each in the 1952 and 1955 World Series. The Dodgers finally produced a title for him in 1955.
 
 

5. Steve Garvey

The Dodgers have a few players during their current run of World Series who seem to rise to the occasion during the postseason, guys like Joc Pederson and Kiké Hernandez. But no Dodger in my viewing experience has put on a consistent show in the Series like Steve Garvey.

Garvey flat-out hit in his World Series appearances. He batted .375 in the 1977 World Series and .417 in the '81 World Series. Before I knew what a clutch-hitter was, it was Garvey in the World Series. He always seemed to produce when it mattered. He hit .319 for his career in the Series.


4. Kirk Gibson

In terms of cumulative performance, Gibson did better for the Tigers in 1984. But nobody outside of Detroit is talking about Gibson's Tigers World Series performance anymore. Gibson had one at-bat for the Dodgers in the World Series. One. And it was the most memorable one World Series at-bat of all-time, starting the Dodgers on its way to upsetting the A's in the 1988 World Series with a pinch-hit winning home run in the ninth on two bad legs.



3. Orel Hershiser

Coming off a record-setting September in 1988 when he set the consecutive scoreless inning streak, Orel Hershiser just kept the fire burning through the rest of the postseason. He won the NLCS MVP award for his performance against the Mets. Then, in the World Series, he threw a complete-game shutout in Game 2 and tossed a complete-game, four-hitter in the decisive Game 5.

The formerly geeky, will-he-ever-make-the-rotation question mark of the Dodgers solidified his legendary status with that one postseason.



2. Sandy Koufax

There is a period in the Dodgers' history when they were winning more World Series than they were losing. That period is from 1955-65 when they won four and lost just one. A big reason for that streak is Sandy Koufax.

Koufax was the main reason why the Yankees endured their first-ever sweep in the Series. He began the 1963 World Series by striking out 15 batters, a record at the time, in his first victory. He then won the decisive Game 4 with another strong performance. In 1965, Koufax famously did not start Game 1 to observe Yom Kippur. He returned for Game 2, but lost. No matter, he threw complete-game shutouts in Game 5 and Game 7 to give the Dodgers the title.


1. Johnny Podres

It must have been tough being a Dodgers fan during the first 52 years that they didn't win a World Series. Seven attempts. No wins.

This is why Johnny Podres is first among the greatest Dodgers World Series heroes. The Yankees won Game 1 and then Game 2 of the 1955 World Series and, oh, here we go. But Podres pitched a complete-game victory on his 23rd birthday in Game 3. He followed that by throwing a complete-game shutout in the Game 7 finale, finally bringing a championship to Brooklyn. He was the consensus top athlete of any sport that year.

People forget that Podres continued to do well in the World Series. He won a game in the 1959 Series and pitched a marvelous game in a victory in the 1963 Series. Who knows how things would have been different in the 1956 Series if Podres didn't miss the entire season due to military service.

So, that's my look at the top World Series heroes for the Dodgers. Apologies to Steve Yeager, Charlie Neal, Pee Wee Reese, Jackie Robinson, Al Gionfriddo, Fernando Valenzuela, Joe Ferguson and Preacher Roe, who all had their notable World Series moments.

Now, with the Dodgers suitably inspired, I expect some results!

Comments

Brett Alan said…
Nice write-up. I'll be rooting for them to come through for you tonight. And I can't imagine anyone has an issue with the blog being Dodger-centric for a while.
simpson said…
I like and understand your rationale for this post - go blue!
acrackedbat said…
With you all the way! I enjoyed this post. Couldn't wait to see who held the number one spot, and deservedly so.
Nick Vossbrink said…
Oh good I had the top 4 right (and in the right order even). Nice to see Essegian get a shout out too.
What? Who the heck are these yahoos, :)
CinciCuse Bill said…
Congratulations to the LA Dodgers and to you Night Owl!
Chris said…
I was worried that all this talk of Dodger heroes would jinx your boys in blue. I'm happy that was not the case. Congrats!
ned said…
Congratulations! It doesn't seem like 32 years!And to me Johnny Podres is still #1
jacobmrley said…
Hey! Guess what I just watched? The Dodgers win the series for the first time in 32 years. Guess who the only person on the entire planet I am happy for given this turn of events? Yup, you Night Owl. Good for you and your team.

Next year in Flushing.
Matt said…
I'm guessing after last night's win a few more current Dodgers may end up on your list! Congrats to the Dodger fandom!
Fuji said…
Happy for you and other Dodger fans. I predicted Koufax and Gibson would be close to the top. Completely forgot about Hershiser... but knew exactly what he did as soon as I saw his name. But never knew about Podres WS heroics. Very cool.
Bo said…
Congratulations!
GCA said…
Jumped right to your blog my first chance today to see how you were celebrating. Guess that'll be up this afternoon.

OK, so the Cubs finally got one...
the Nationals finally got one...
and the Dodgers finally got one after a while...

Who's next?
Congratulations on the victory.
I agree with the Pods choice. The first one is always the best.

Kirk Gibson was the real-life Roy Hobbs!

Popular posts from this blog

Greatest 100 cards of the '80s: progress report 3 ... and a date

  Big news! I have a date set for the Greatest 100 Cards of the '80s countdown! I didn't want to post a date until I had whittled my list of card candidates down to the final 100. But I just did that today and ... wow, was that tough to do. As is often the case when I do long-form countdowns like this -- the Greatest Cards of the '70s, the Best Dodger Cards Ever Made -- I feel a bit sorry for the cards that just missed the cut. There is nothing wrong with those cards. And on another day, maybe they would make the countdown. But this is the kind of ruthless examination that you've come to expect on this blog and, so, I will deliver.   Here are five cards that did not make the final 100 but if the ranking went to 105 places, they would be there. Also, I'm going to give you a chance to vote one in!   1980 Topps Frank White I have long loved this card and have mentioned it a few times on the blog. It's one of the best All-Star cards made since I started collecting c

The curse and gift of being an introvert

    I finished a week-long binge session of "The Queen's Gambit" Thanksgiving night.   Unlike many of my wife's Netflix interests, things like "The Crown" and various family comedy/dramas, I knew I'd be interested in "Gambit" while she was watching it. I'm a sucker for the "intelligent, pretty girl breaks up the boys club" story, and the fact that it featured chess was intriguing.   I haven't played chess since I was a teenager, but I used to play it regularly, not that I was any good. My uncle was. He would play in various local tournaments and come back with stories about the weird habits and tactics of his chess rivals. The gist of his stories was "this is something you don't want to do." But it sure sounded interesting. As Anya Taylor-Joy says, the mini-series isn't really about chess. The character she plays, Beth Harmon, has a lot of problems, a terrible family back story and substance abuse issues. She

Catch this!

I have long admired this card.   It's an Awesome Night Card from way back and it was one of the only 1986 Topps cards that I owned in 1986. I don't remember at all buying packs of cards in '86 and I had so few that year, but I must have bought some because I've known about that Bo Diaz card for 35 years.   I've known about it for so long that it seemed a given for the upcoming Greatest 100 Cards of the '80s countdown. A tag at the plate was relatively rare on cards in the '80s and to get the entire scene in the frame, and also knowing who is being tagged out , was an achievement. It is an achievement. (Also, they're somehow playing while it's snowing). But after reviewing eligible candidates for the countdown, I began to have my doubts. Oh, that's not taking anything away from the Diaz card. It's still great. But have you noticed how terrific the catcher cards are in 1986 Topps? We'll start from the beginning. At card No. 88 is Tom Niet