data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1a196/1a19623ef05aca2c31f54f5d664792d83b40dc55" alt=""
I think motherscratcher said it best in the comments. You've got to pick a Reggie that looks like Reggie. The 1970 card features a very nice photo and all, but that isn't the Reggie that anyone remembers.
The 1978 Reggie Jackson card features a Reggie that looks like Reggie, doing what Reggie does. Or did. And in a last-minute flurry of poll activity, the '78 Jackson card rallied from second place to overtake the '70 card by a single vote. I'm proud to say the 1978 card is the best Jackson card of the '70s.
The last time I did this, with Johnny Bench, the post segued into the "I'm Badass and You're Not" feature, and Bench was entered into the "badass" club. So, the question is, does Reggie gain entrance into the badass club now?
Well ... here's the thing. I want to add him. He was certainly badass in terms of his playing ability. There is almost nothing more badass than hitting titanic home runs (personally, I think striking 300 batters or gunning down someone at home plate is more badass, but to each his own). Reggie also featured the badass look with the mustache and shades.
But I can't put him in the club. He talked too much. All that whining and straw-stirring and babbling about me, me, me. Badasses don't babble. They barely talk. They certainly don't whine. They don't advertise their badassness (I'm just making up words on the spot now) with their mouths. They just go about their awesome business, and if others don't appreciate it, then it doesn't matter, because, well, they're badass and you're not.
So, Jackson's not in the club. Not yet, anyway. I won't rule him out for good. But it does mean I need to find someone else to fill the third spot. And I've got the perfect person.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/306c8/306c86344f5a98d2c797e30913219cf16be84520" alt=""
But despite the long hair and sideburns, us kids weren't impressed. His career .205 batting average at the time didn't help matters either. My brothers and I would line up our '75 cards in order by batting average and Thomas was right there at the bottom with Mario Mendoza.
But turn to the back of that card and there is a telling glimpse of the badassery to come:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2e608/2e60843febcda558ebe558b6c7788422c3ff69f4" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/28eee/28eeec12edb3b0ac55eb16be7ad864de6533e74d" alt=""
Thomas simply looked like a beer-drinking, softball-playing, truck-driving man. And if you want more proof, look at the back of his 1980 Kellogg's card.
Plus, Thomas could hit home runs like Reggie. In fact, he tied Jackson for the home run title in 1980 and won the AL title in 1979 with 45. He hit 51 in the minors for Sacramento in 1974. Thomas was part of the 1982 Harvey's Wallbangers team that reached the World Series, a squad filled with motley members, who I'm told had just as much fun off the field as on the field. Thomas was the last out in the '82 World Series. In other words, he was The Blob. But I'm willing to overlook that. Body of work, we're going with here.
Thomas was traded to the Indians the next year and his career ended in 1986. Now, Stormin' Gorman does appearances for the Brewers, and he's as popular as ever. Because he's Badass and You're Not.
Plus, Thomas could hit home runs like Reggie. In fact, he tied Jackson for the home run title in 1980 and won the AL title in 1979 with 45. He hit 51 in the minors for Sacramento in 1974. Thomas was part of the 1982 Harvey's Wallbangers team that reached the World Series, a squad filled with motley members, who I'm told had just as much fun off the field as on the field. Thomas was the last out in the '82 World Series. In other words, he was The Blob. But I'm willing to overlook that. Body of work, we're going with here.
Thomas was traded to the Indians the next year and his career ended in 1986. Now, Stormin' Gorman does appearances for the Brewers, and he's as popular as ever. Because he's Badass and You're Not.
Comments
Gorman is definately badass. Good call.
One thing about the post: Take the sentence "Thomas was traded to the Indians the next year and his career ended in 1986."
Now remove "in 1986". The sentence makes just as much, if not more, sense. Ah, the 1980's Indians. Where careers went to die.