Skip to main content

C.A.: 2008 Topps Stadium Club Justin Upton (yes, I finally completed the damn thing)

(Welcome to the first day of Gerrit Cole as a New York Yankee. In true Yankee fashion, the Cole news not only annoyed me on a baseball level, but from a job perspective as well, announced after midnight, approximately 30 minutes before deadline, forcing absolute chaos in an attempt to get it  published in the paper. So those of you who woke up to the news and announced it as if it was a new thing, I have one thing I wanna say: I KNOW!!!!!!!! Welcome to Cardboard Appreciation. This is the 287th in a series):

Eleven years ago, I did a dumb thing.

I decided to attempt to complete the new Topps Stadium Club set, which was released in early November of 2008.

I liked the look of the cards. It was the first Stadium Club set in five years. And, I was attempting to complete a lot of 2008 sets that year because that's what I did then. Got to complete what's on store shelves, right?

Well, 2008 Stadium Club showed me the error of my thinking.

The set is basically impossible to complete.

Card No. 94 of the 150-card set (if you include the autographed cards in the set, it balloons to 185 cards, but I'm not counting those) does not exist. It was supposed to be Joe DiMaggio but somewhere in the process of making the set, Topps lost the DiMaggio licensing rights to Upper Deck. So the DiMaggio card was pulled but there are apparently "cut-out" DiMaggio cards from the set if you can find one.

I'm not going to find one.

Early in the process of trying to complete the set, I discovered I was pulling the same cards over and over. Adrian Gonzalez was one. Roy Halladay was another. Joba Chamberlain, too. Over and over.

That was because every third card in the set, all of the cards with a number divisible by three, were short-printed to 999 copies. They're not that easy to find. But you could get around that by finding the parallel version, the first-day issue cards, which are easier to land but you still got to search.

So, I decided, if I want to complete this thing, I have to go for the first-day issue cards for all the divisible-by-three cards.

Then there are the two different kinds of rookie player cards, which make up the back half of the set. Each rookie player has two cards with a different image on each one. One has a first-day issue stamp and the other does not. But some of the rookie player cards have two different images with first-day issue stamps on each of them for reasons I don't know.

Got all that?

I had no idea what I was getting into.

It became Night Owl's Great Mistake in my mind. I liked many of the 2008 sets and I wanted to complete them. I wanted to complete Allen & Ginter from that year as well as Heritage, featuring the cool 1959 design, and Upper Deck Timeline and Stadium Club. I sort of half wanted to complete Masterpieces, too.

Well, I did complete Allen & Ginter. But Heritage still isn't complete. I gave up on Timeline and traded off some of the cards. I haven't given any extra thought to Masterpieces.

But Stadium Club, dammit, I was determined to complete.

It took 11 years, and the last few years, I grabbed maybe one card a year, but, finally, with the arrival of the Justin Upton First-Day Issue card that you saw at the top of the post, my set is complete -- by my standards.

Here is a look at all of the cards now:

As you can see I left a blank spot where the DiMaggio card was supposed to go. The way I have them placed in the pages is kind of a holdover from how I used to think about modern cards: must try to collect every single one!

Also, if I managed to find both rookie images, I put both cards in the pages side-by-side. Now that the set is complete, I'll probably rework those cards and scrap the double-bagging. I may put this set in with the only other Stadium Club set I have completed, the 2015 set. Although I don't know if the '08 set deserves to be in with the very fine, very nonconfusing 2015 set.

The images in the 2008 set are as nice as the other Stadium Club versions, but the set didn't sell well, probably because of the crazy configuration. Stadium Club didn't appear on the market again until 2014, and even then that was hobby only as a wary Topps tested the waters after the '08 disaster.

I know that thanks to the '08 fiasco, I will never go into a modern set blind again. I will try out a set for awhile before deciding I want to complete it, because one of the worst feelings is giving up in the middle of a set, knowing you can't complete it.

Fortunately, I can say that with 2008 Stadium Club, it is complete. As complete as it's going to get anyway. And there's no chance I will try to chase down any of those other numbered to 999 cards or any of the extra images of the rookie players.

Eleven years later, after many of the careers of the players featured in the set are finished, I am finished also.


Nick said…
Congrats on yet another completed set! Also much thanks for posting all the cards together like that -- given Stadium Club's recent resurgence, I sometimes forget how nice this particular set really was.
Lee Hero said…
Geez. I was out of the game in 2008, but just reading all of that made my head hurt! Congratulations on completing such a daunting task.
Trevor P said…
I had no idea that the set was so complicated. Congrats on finishing it. I tend to think like you; I have my own idea of what's "complete." I have to say, though, it would bother me to see all those First-Day stamps in my set. For no other reason than it would remind me of what a pain in the butt the set is.
Nachos Grande said…
This is a good year for finishing sets from 2008! I finally finished off that UD Timelines set that you mentioned above. Like you, I went guns blazing in 2008 trying to complete sets (so much so that I'm still working on both the 2008 Heritage and the 2008 Goudey sets). For my money, my biggest mistake was probably trying to tackle Goudey with all of its (expensive) short prints...things I wasn't much aware of back in '08.
Adam Kaningher said…
The thing I remember most about this set is that Garrett Atkins's card has the wrong color-coding.
Billy Kingsley said…
That seems like a really frustrating set to collect. What were they thinking short printing a third of the cards?
Bo said…
If you ever get the itch to work on '08 Masterpieces, let me know. I have almost all of 1-90 and a few of the higher numbers for trade.
GCA said…
Holy corporate complications, Batman! That strikes that set from the list of potential targets for me. I can just picture a committee of hot shot executives saying "Let's be innovative. OK, we'll short print just every third card. And have parallels. Are they short printed too? Nah. Just throw it all together...."

I"m working on Timelines too. Don't think I have a list up yet. The back end of that one seems to have more than meets the eye too. I'm one to quickly dismiss "all the rookies at the end" for a lot of products and call them done.
Brad Hill said…
That's such a confusing set. But I honestly like confusing.
Fuji said…
Congratulations on completing this gorgeous set! I figured something was a little funky when I started chasing the Max Scherzer rookie card from this set. Pretty sure I've seen at least 3 different copies of his card.
Defenders50 said…
This is a very catharsis filled post. I think I got a whiff of it and I'm pretty sure I'll never come close to completing the set myself.
carlsonjok said…
Well done on completing that set. And, given your lede, I am rather miffed about the Cole signing and I'm a Yankee fan. Who gives a 9 year, $300M+ contract to a pitcher? I wouldn't give that to a position player, with the sole exception of Mike Trout.
Jafronius said…
Congrats on the set completion. You put 2 cards in per pocket?
Ryan G said…
Congratulations! I finished this set last year, and did the same thing as you - any of the parallels were adequate. Got the rookie photo variations, too. I’m stupid enough to be working on the autographs, down to seven. That includes Scherzer and Keyshawn though!

Popular posts from this blog

BIG numbers

This is one of those milestone things that used to mean a lot more.Back in my first year or two of blogging, I'd note the milestones that passed and really celebrate them as if they were a big deal. And they really did seem like a big deal at the time:300th post. Wooo!400th post. Weee!500th post. Well that was kind of lame.900th post. You could tell I was already getting sick of coming up with milestone post ideas.But I still like celebrating milestones, no matter what form they take. Not only does it satisfy my compulsion to categorize with numbers, but a nice, big, round number is proof that you've been doing something for awhile -- and if it's worth keeping track of, then probably that thing you've been doing for awhile is enjoyable.So even though I don't flip out quite as much over blog milestones, I've reached yet another one and here I am mentioning it.
I've surpassed 3 million views, you guys.Just once I'd like to witness the odometer turning over…

Card stuff I discovered on the internet

This post was originally going to be called "stuff I discovered on the internet," but I figured that would leave too much to the imagination.Before the internet came along, I discovered cards and card sets mostly through advertisements in the Sporting News or Baseball Digest, or through hobby catalogs that came to my house, like TCMA or Fritsch Cards. Later, I subscribed to Baseball Cards Magazine and found new-to-me sets in articles in that magazine.But I missed so much through those methods. Outside of what was selling in wax or cello packs at the drug or grocery store, that was all I knew.It wasn't until years and years later, when I ended up online like everyone else, that I discovered how much that I had missed.Once I became aware of card blogs, the door was open wider than ever. There were so many sets -- so many sets and cards that often had been issued right under my nose -- that I never knew existed.For example:
I had no idea there were so many box sets from Flee…

Overwhelmed then underwhelmed

Well, welcome back card aisle, you're looking rather ... uh ... disorderly.This was the sight at my neighborhood Target yesterday. As disorganized and scattered as it appears, I can count three different baseball card products (four, if you add the MLB stickers) in just this small crop of the card aisle.This is as many different kinds of baseball card products that I've seen on area store shelves since March. With Covid quarantining and the inexplicable ransacking of card shelves across the country, I've purchased almost no cards in person for the last six months. (On Twitter I mentioned these were the first 2020 baseball cards I had seen on shelves since March, which isn't quite true. I forgot I picked up a couple of scattered packs of Series two a couple of months ago. That's how forgettable Topps flagship is this year).Within that frame are a couple of hanger boxes of 2020 Topps Fire, a half-filled gravity feeder of 2020 Stadium Club and, up at the top, a gravit…