Skip to main content

The best Dodger card for every year I've collected: update

Next year will mark 45 years since I first started collecting cards.

Now don't worry. That doesn't make me feel old. When it's been 50 years, then I'll feel old.

A couple of years ago, I wrote a post to track my favorite Topps flagship Dodger card for every year since I started collecting. I make a selection in my head every year so it was about time I documented it somewhere.

I still haven't accumulated every Dodger card from this year's flagship. I came up empty with the packs I bought yesterday and I'm still three cards short -- Bellinger, Buehler and Ryu ... hmmm, isn't that funny, only the three players doing the best for the Dodgers this year.

But I've seen the card images for each and they're nothing but run-of-the-mill action shots. Nothing that will be in contention for 2019's best Dodger card.

But before I get to 2019, I'll show the 2018 card. Two years ago I finished up my list through 2017.

The 2018 card is easy. It was also my favorite card regardless of 2018:

Still a cool card.

Now we're at 2019 and I'll run through the candidates.

The Ross Stripling card above is a candidate just because it's a rare close-up action shot with an atypical crop. It's also the only one of the candidates that breaks through the design, which I like a lot. But the throwing hand is cut off and it annoys me just a little so I'm not selecting it.

Candidate 2 is David Freese, gesturing as he rounds the bases after hitting a home run. The last two years of Dodgers cards have been heavy on postseason images and this is one of them: Freese's first-inning home run in Game 5 of last year's World Series.

But we all know how that ended and the home run didn't even get the Dodgers the lead so painful memories regardless of the celebration.

Third candidate. Fun card. A particularly fun card for a Dodger fan if Barnes did indeed catch the nasty Giant's pop up. (It actually looks like it's out of play).

This potentially could have worked better as a vertical card (although the original photo is cropped as a horizontal) and all I think of when I see this is how marginal Barnes is as a major league player. So this isn't the best either.

By process of elimination, here is my favorite flagship Dodger card for 2019.

It's not a strong choice. Even though Kiké Hernandez made a terrific sliding catch on this ball against the Angels in July of 2018, there's an awkwardness about it when cropped down to the area of a baseball card. Still, Hernandez will never be known as the most graceful player, so this is the winner.

And now it's time for a rundown of the best for every year:













































You can see that nine of the last 10 favorites have been from landscape cards. As long as Topps continues to include horizontal shots and rely on Getty Images for photos, I don't see the traditional vertical card photo breaking through too often in the future.

OK, I'm off to grab those last three 2019 Dodgers needs -- hopefully from someone pleasant enough not to make me pay a buck fifty for a flagship card of Bellinger.


Zvon said…
Allow me to reiterate:
(said that on twitter too, lol)
Trevor P said…
I especially like the Dodgers logo flying off the bat in the 1997 Delino.
John Bateman said…
I thought you were going with the Austin Barnes card - that one is pretty amazing and reminds me of a 1950's posed photo.
John Bateman said…
Also, the 1988 Lasorda, a card before its time, might be the best out of all of these.
Old Cards said…
Great lineup of cards! Don't want to be greedy, but would really like to see your favorite Dodger cards prior to 1975. Maybe, 1957 thru 1974. Only 18 more cards.
CrazieJoe said…
Nice how the 2009 design, instead of just a close up of the pitcher, getting the batter in the shot as well makes a huge difference on how interesting and better the card is.
Fuji said…
Great selection of cards! The 1991 Fernando, 2003 Nomo, and 2018 Buehler are probably my top 3. I guess I have a thing for pitchers and action shots.

Popular posts from this blog

A friend indeed

This week has been the kind of week that only late January could produce.

Nothing particularly wrong or terrible happened. Mostly what I felt this week was a sense of spinning my wheels, of working hard without result (or with other people screwing it up), of trying to get things accomplished (while battling a sinus infection) only to have a car noise or a phone call knock me back to square one.

That feeling transferred over to the blog where I probably spent too much time uploading too many photos and conducting too much research and expecting too much in return.

But all of this is a phase. It's the January malaise. I'll snap out of it. It could be worse. I could be dealing with three feet of snow right now instead of the melting three inches that is out there.

And I could be struggling through this week without an envelope in the mail from "A Friend".

That's right, "A Friend".

That's how the return address appeared on the envelope. Just above th…

Degrees of doneness

I just wrapped up my first notable card purchase of 2020.

It was an online order -- from three of every collector's favorite card-buying sites -- and with the exception of three inserts from 2019 and a stray card from 1989, every single card I ordered was made prior to 1980.

That feels good. That feels tremendously good.

I'm starting off 2020 in the right frame of mind.

It's also a good way to put a cork in the 2019 collecting season. There are various ways you can say you're done with the cards from the previous year, call it degrees of doneness, if you will (I order steaks "medium" or "medium well," I don't need anything crawling off my plate).

1. You can be done with collecting sets from 2019. I'm certainly done with that. I didn't try to collect many sets from that year anyway. The 2019 Topps Holiday set and a third of the 2019 Topps Archives set are finished and that's everything I plan to do.

2. You can be done with buying pac…

The lone Ranger

Who is Nick Solak?

Glad you asked.

And thanks to cynicalbuddha for scanning his card into Trading Card Database.

Nick Solak is a former Yankees, former Rays prospect who appeared in 33 games for the Texas Rangers last year.

That, apparently, qualifies him for being the only Texas Ranger to appear in the 350-card base set for 2020 Topps Series 1, a checklist of which was released this morning.

That's right, the ONLY Texas Ranger.

I did the count and the Rangers, with Solak shouldering the entire load, come up a distant 30th behind the 29th-place Orioles, who have a more typical seven cards.

Here is the breakdown by team that I compiled earlier:

Dodgers - 17
Astros - 17
Nationals - 16
Cubs - 15
Athletics - 14
Brewers - 14
Indians - 14
White Sox - 14
Phillies - 13
Angels - 12
Blue Jays - 12
Braves - 12
Padres - 12
Red Sox - 12
Reds - 12
Twins - 12
Yankees - 12
Cardinals - 11
Giants - 11
Marlins - 11
Mets - 11
Diamondbacks - 10
Mariners - 10
Rays - 10
Tigers - 10
Royals - 9
Pirates -…