Tuesday, August 15, 2017

The best Dodger card for every year I've collected


Here's a fun exercise if you don't mind scanning and cropping until your eyes bleed.

As a team collector, I have been accumulating Dodgers from the Topps flagship set each year for 42 years, with a few breaks here and there (in light of that, the post for this title should read "The best Dodger card for every year since I started collecting" -- but that isn't nearly as punchy).

Every year, whether consciously or without really thinking about it, I select my favorite Dodger card from that particular year. I figure that it's beyond past time to post each of those cards here.

This goes back to 1975, the first year I actually collected cards. And I'm limiting it to Topps flagship, both for sanity reasons and also because for the first six years that's all there was. I'm also trying to preserve history as much as I can by posting what my favorite card was back then when the set came out. No revisionist history here even though I'm sure my views have changed for some of the sets issued back when I was a kid.

OK, so here is the 42-year rundown:

1975

1976

1977

1978

1979

1980

1981

1982

1983

1984

1985

1986

1987

1988

1989

1990

1991

1992

1993

1994

1995

1996

1997

1998

1999

2000

2001

2002

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

2011

2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

2017


OK, now for some notes and explainers for each year, if I have something.

1975: Duh.
1976: I was also particularly in love with the Andy Messersmith card from this year, but Marshall won out because the action was so tremendous I could barely stand it.
1979: The start of my rookie obsession.
1980: Cey edged out Rick Sutcliffe as rookie obsession was still very strong.
1981: More rookie obsession.
1986: Pedro Guerrero is the only player to show three times as my favorite card.
1989: Only night card in the set.
1992: Only Lasorda could make a manager card the best card of the year twice.
2000: Not a great card, but so happy Hershiser was back with the Dodgers.
2002: The period from 2000-07 is pretty awful. A lot of sameness with every card, and very difficult to pick some years. Thank goodness there was a night card this year.
2007: The worst year of all. Maddux, in a photoshopped Dodger uniform mind you, is only there because I was so thrilled to see Maddux as a Dodger.
2010: The start of the horizontal era.
2016: Puig is my favorite because it's the card that's the most effective at negating the smoke factor.

In somewhat of a coincidence, my favorite players show up the most often.

Pedro Guerrero - 3
Ron Cey - 2
Orel Hershiser - 2
Clayton Kershaw - 2
Raul Mondesi - 2
Hideo Nomo - 2

And, of course, Tommy Lasorda - 2

So that satisfies yet another curiosity of mine.

Feel free to do this with your own favorite team. Although if you've been collecting as long as I have, you may want to block out an afternoon.

15 comments:

  1. The '91 Fernando and '03 Nomo are great. Anything that captures their unique wind-ups would be a keeper in my book. I have the John Tudor in my base card binders. It's one of the few '89 Topps cards I like (Bill Bene is another, mostly because it reminds me of my father in law)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Cool idea and great execution! I'll go with the '03 Nomo as well.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Curious why you like that '82 choice. Personally my favorite Dodger card from '82 would be the Mike Scioscia card. Love the action of it. Guerrero is a cool dude & was one of my favorite Dodgers too, but, how does it beat a card with a catcher going for a ball and whipping off his mask? I'm interested to know what you see in that one that I'm not.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Guerrero was a young star player who had won the World Series MVP the previous year. Topps robbed the Dodgers of getting their own World Series subset that year, so I gravitated toward that card.

      Delete
    2. OOohh yeah, I can see that now. As much as I love the '82 set, I think I would prefer it to have a World Series subset instead of the "in action" subset. Those action shots should've just been used for regular cards. It even felt a bit weird to me as a kid that they'd have these extra cards of players just to show them in action when they could've done that in their main card anyway.

      Delete
  4. When I think about Dodgers Topps flagship cards, two immediately come to mind:

    #1: 2004 Topps Hideo Nomo
    #2: 1977 Topps Steve Garvey

    I'll definitely be adding that 1991 Topps Fernando Valenzuela to the list. That card is beautiful. The 83T Stew and 84T Reuss are also really nice.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Fun stuff! That 1994 is *so* Roger McDowell that it hurts. I'm going to consider this to be a Bat-Around and do it for the Mets, but as I'd have to go back to 1974 and have little time as it is, who knows when it will see the light of day. Thank you for limiting this to Topps flagship, though.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Couple that I thought you might pick instead were:
    2011 Dee Gordon - it was your 2011 card of the year as well as one of your 50 greatest Dodger cards of All-Time.
    1981 Pedro Guerrero - Great dugout shot of Pedro compared to Rudy. Plus, they both already shared a rookie card in 1979.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Gordon was in the Update set, not counting those ... Liked the '81 Guerrero a lot but in '81 I was all about Rudy Law.

      Delete
  7. I enjoyed your list -- I only collected seriously from 1987-1994, so I hadn't seen a lot of these. I also stopped watching baseball altogether for several years after the 1994 strike. I didn't realize Orel Hershiser had such a long career. I know I have a few of these, especially the Bob Welch rookie.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Everyone has the Bob Welch. It could have made my list of cards that show up the most.

      Lasorda could be an all-time classic card great.

      Delete
  8. Cool. sadly some of the later ones I haven't seen because I don't have the full flagship sets of much of any flagship set. 1994's McDowell made me think Samurai. Oh great now I have visions of Samurai John Belushi hacking up everything in sight. Samurai pinch hitter.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I love that 1992 Lasorda card - a manager visibly leading his team! Brilliant...

    ReplyDelete
  10. I love the Lasorda cards. Some of the few manager cards that Topps did a good job with during that time period. For some reason I always liked the 78 Ron Cey, but can't argue with the choice of Dusty Baker.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Awesome post! Cool to see Eddie on there, though I think his 1991 card is even better...

    ReplyDelete