Skip to main content

The 1975 Topps countdown, worst to best (No. 123-104)

 
Well, three out of the four posts I've made this week have some sort of mention of 1975 Topps, so why not make it 4-for-5, that always sound better than 3-for-4 in the baseball realm.

Once I get through this episode of the countdown, there will be just 100 cards left, which means nothing but greatness ahead.

So let's get to it, no fancy intro this time.
 
 

123: Ed Kranepool (card 324)

Still quite a few Mets cards remaining as they really cleaned up in this set. I remember hearing Ed Kranepool talked about with the same reverence as Tom Seaver from Mets fans when I was a kid in the '70s.



122. Bob Reynolds (card 142)

I really liked this card in '75, it looked like Bob Reynolds was pointing at me, and that's all you want as a young fan, for a ballplayer to point you out.



121. Jim Bibby (card 155)

Every Rangers card was great in 1975, but this was one of the best. Jim Bibby seemed like he coming through the card, no doubt because he was 6-foot-5.



120. Pat Bourque (card 502)

This is the ultimate in the first baseman's pose, show that ball in the glove! Also, this card is all about yellow and green.



119. Jose Cardenal (card 15)

Jose Cardenal had one of the ultimate 1970s Afros, which is why this card is where it is. Still not as great as his 1977 card though.



118. Frank Duffy (card 448)

I have known this card for a long time, almost 50 years, it was everywhere in 1975, and in mini size, too. Frank Duffy was a "common" and I didn't think much of it, but years later it's a classic great pose.



117. Ed Kirkpatrick (card 171)

The casual catcher's pose is highly underrated.



116. George Hendrick (card 109)

One of the most-pleasing uniform-border matches in the set. I could fill a whole page with this card.



115. Jack Brohamer (card 552)

Even though Jack Brohamer is likely posing, it still seems like too tough a task to be smiling through it and it gives the impression that Brohamer is absolutely delighted when he fields a ball during a game.



114. John Milner (card 264)

John Milner has a lot of 1970s cards in which he's in this same pose, year-after-year, but this is the best-looking one.



113. Bake McBride (card 174)

More rookie cup greatness and the signature in which Bake McBride puts "Bake" in quotes is great. This card was a favorite of mine as I pulled it on a family vacation on a hot day. Nine-year-old me is mad this isn't in the top 100.



112 Dave Kingman (card 156)

I first knew Dave Kingman as a New York Met. I'd go to my grandma and grandpa's and there he was on the TV as a Met. So when I came across this card later (I never saw it in '75), it was strange seeing him as a San Francisco Giant. It didn't seem real.



111. Willie Horton (card 66)

Willie Horton is wearing a helmet and a big ol' mustache. It was my first look at a handlebar fu manchu mustache, I'm quite sure. Had I known that Willie Horton kept the same helmet his whole career and just repainted it depending on his team, I never would have traded away this card (which I did).



110. Ted Simmons (card 75)

The most regal look in the '75 set. Ted Simmons has an air of superiority about him, no doubt brought on my his long mane of hair. This card shocked me as a youngster. But there is absolutely no doubt that it's great.



109. Don Wilson (card 455)

There are other cards in this set of players who were dead when it was released -- most related to the MVP subset -- but there is just one card of a player who was active during the 1974 season and then was dead when the set was released. Wilson died of carbon monoxide poisoning on Jan. 5, which apparently was too late for Topps to remove the card or write anything about Wilson's passing on the back.
 

108. Garry Maddox (card 240)
 
Another favorite, I pulled this card from the same pack as the Bake McBride. It was really a great pack. The way this photo is shot is everything, I love the cloudless blue background with the blue border and Maddox looks cool as hell.
 
 

107. Home Run Leaders - 1974 (card 307)

More grand posing for the sluggers of the day. Both seem to have spotted something somewhat concerning in the sky.
 
 

106. '74 A.L. Championships (card 459)

This is a nifty double-play turn and the teams match the ALCS combatants, but it appears that this is a photo from a regular-season game, given the lack of a matching play in the '74 ALCS and also the rather sparse crowd in the stands. Probably would have awarded a better rating if it was playoff shot.



105. World Series - 1974, Game 4 (card 464)

A's pitcher Ken Holtzman hit a home run in Game 4 of the World Series and this appears to be that play. Moment-in-time cards are the very best cards, it's just too bad the Dodgers had to suffer here.



104. '74 N.L. Championships (card 460)

Steve Garvey is dusting himself off after sliding into second with a double while the Pirates' Frank Taveras sadly berates the baseball for arriving late. I've long loved this card and it has a special spot in my heart among Dodger cards in my collection.

As we near the top 100. I can tell you there is one more leaders card to get to, two more postseason cards and two more Highlights cards. But that's all I'll tell you.

Except ... more to come! 

Comments

The dust in 101 makes me weep with nostalgia.
Nick Vossbrink said…
Now wondering if anyone's sent that Garvey dust card out TTM
Old Cards said…
Sad to see Bake didn't make the top 100. The Horton mustache looks more like a fu manchu than a handlebar to me. Great cards!
night owl said…
I mixed my mustache descriptions, I must be slipping!
steelehere said…
That Garvey card has to be in the top 3 of all time cloud of dust cards with 1976 Topps Johnny Bench and 1971 Topps Thurman Munson.

Honorable mention to 1973 Topps Pat Corrales and Oscar Gamble, 1977 Topps Maury Wills and Carlton Fisk, 1972 Topps In Action Willie Mays and Luis Aparicio and many, many others.
sg488 said…
I loved that Garvey card for years ,trying to pinpoint the game it had to be game 1 in Pittsburgh it's the only double he hit in the series and he didn't steal any bases.
Jamie Meyers said…
I sent the playoff card to Garvey and he signed it TTM.
Old Cards said…
Appreciate your blog!!
I used to be of the opinion that the Mets should've retired Kranepool's number as he had played in each of the team's first 18 seasons, beginning with a 1962 cup off coffee as a 17-year-old. His having been there from the start and being a local boy made him very special at the time.

My favorite part of Bourque's card is on the back where it says something like: "He came to the Twins during the season blah blah blah... No, wait, he's back with the A's now"
Chris said…
Kirkpatrick, Hendrick, and the playoff cards pop out at me. The Simmons is memorable for sure. I didn't know Don Wilson's story, or that Topps didn't indicate anything about his death.
Fuji said…
Both of those action shots on the A's playoff cards are really nice. Nice detective work on the Robinson/Green card. I automatically assumed it had to be from one of their playoff games. And that Holtzman is amazing. Great angle by the photographer... and cropping by Topps.
Bo said…
Nice backgrounds on Bourque and Hendrick.
1984 Tigers said…
These cards are awesome and still didn't make the top 100. A few photos are likely from the 73 season, not 74. The ones with silent George and Allen leader both look like Yankee Stadium, while the Yanks played at Shea for 74 and 75 while the stadium was being refurbished.

Willie Horton was one of my favorite players growing up in Detroit. My mother in law got his auto at an event nearby some years ago. It was on a customized card that also shared his faith journey on the back. That photo is clearly from Lakeland where the Tigers have trained for decades.
GCA said…
With Simmons and Wilson together, I'd say you had just read my last case opening post.